柏杨译“大力水手”的个案分析

Research output: Journal PublicationsJournal Article (refereed)Researchpeer-review

Abstract

<Chi>在一九六八年的台湾,发生了一件由翻译引发的案件——作家柏杨因漫画"大力水手"中的几句翻译而锒铛入狱。本文结合Lefevere的有关翻译理论对柏杨的翻译以及他获罪原因进行分析,并对有关翻译与意识形态关系的问题进行探讨。通过"大力水手"这一个案研究,我们可以看到,翻译虽然在特定情况下与一定历史时期的意识形态有紧密的关系,但讨论翻译与意识形态的问题,不能简单机械地套用某些翻译理论,而要尽可能多地考虑到多方面的因素,这样才可以对翻译作品及译者有公正客观的评价。<Chi><Eng>There was an incident arising from translation in Taiwan in 1968: a writer named Bo Yang was imprisoned simply because of the wording in his translation of the comic Popeye. This paper analyzes the reason of his imprisonment by applying Lefevere’s translation theory and further discusses the relationship between translation and ideology. Through the analysis of the case of the "Popeye Incident", we may see that, although translation is inseparable from certain ideology at certain historical period, we should not simply apply translation theory mechanically; instead we should take as many factors as possible into consideration and thus we may do justice to the translations as well as the translators.<Eng>
Original languageChinese (Simplified)
Pages (from-to)56-61, 78
Number of pages7
Journal当代外语研究 = Contemporary Foreign Languages Studies
Volume2014
Issue number7
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Jul 2014
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

Ideology
Translation Theory
Writer
Historical Periods
Justice
Imprisonment
Translator
Taiwan

Keywords

  • 翻译
  • 意识形态
  • "大力水手"
  • 柏杨

Cite this

@article{d6210469e29e4242859a1088dc8a25e7,
title = "柏杨译“大力水手”的个案分析",
abstract = "<Chi>在一九六八年的台湾,发生了一件由翻译引发的案件——作家柏杨因漫画{"}大力水手{"}中的几句翻译而锒铛入狱。本文结合Lefevere的有关翻译理论对柏杨的翻译以及他获罪原因进行分析,并对有关翻译与意识形态关系的问题进行探讨。通过{"}大力水手{"}这一个案研究,我们可以看到,翻译虽然在特定情况下与一定历史时期的意识形态有紧密的关系,但讨论翻译与意识形态的问题,不能简单机械地套用某些翻译理论,而要尽可能多地考虑到多方面的因素,这样才可以对翻译作品及译者有公正客观的评价。<Chi><Eng>There was an incident arising from translation in Taiwan in 1968: a writer named Bo Yang was imprisoned simply because of the wording in his translation of the comic Popeye. This paper analyzes the reason of his imprisonment by applying Lefevere’s translation theory and further discusses the relationship between translation and ideology. Through the analysis of the case of the {"}Popeye Incident{"}, we may see that, although translation is inseparable from certain ideology at certain historical period, we should not simply apply translation theory mechanically; instead we should take as many factors as possible into consideration and thus we may do justice to the translations as well as the translators.<Eng>",
keywords = "翻译, 意识形态, {"}大力水手{"}, 柏杨",
author = "白立平",
year = "2014",
month = "7",
doi = "10.3969/j.issn.1674-8921.2014.07.011",
language = "Chinese (Simplified)",
volume = "2014",
pages = "56--61, 78",
journal = "当代外语研究 = Contemporary Foreign Languages Studies",
issn = "1674-8921",
number = "7",

}

柏杨译“大力水手”的个案分析. / 白立平.

In: 当代外语研究 = Contemporary Foreign Languages Studies, Vol. 2014, No. 7, 07.2014, p. 56-61, 78.

Research output: Journal PublicationsJournal Article (refereed)Researchpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - 柏杨译“大力水手”的个案分析

AU - 白立平, null

PY - 2014/7

Y1 - 2014/7

N2 - <Chi>在一九六八年的台湾,发生了一件由翻译引发的案件——作家柏杨因漫画"大力水手"中的几句翻译而锒铛入狱。本文结合Lefevere的有关翻译理论对柏杨的翻译以及他获罪原因进行分析,并对有关翻译与意识形态关系的问题进行探讨。通过"大力水手"这一个案研究,我们可以看到,翻译虽然在特定情况下与一定历史时期的意识形态有紧密的关系,但讨论翻译与意识形态的问题,不能简单机械地套用某些翻译理论,而要尽可能多地考虑到多方面的因素,这样才可以对翻译作品及译者有公正客观的评价。<Chi><Eng>There was an incident arising from translation in Taiwan in 1968: a writer named Bo Yang was imprisoned simply because of the wording in his translation of the comic Popeye. This paper analyzes the reason of his imprisonment by applying Lefevere’s translation theory and further discusses the relationship between translation and ideology. Through the analysis of the case of the "Popeye Incident", we may see that, although translation is inseparable from certain ideology at certain historical period, we should not simply apply translation theory mechanically; instead we should take as many factors as possible into consideration and thus we may do justice to the translations as well as the translators.<Eng>

AB - <Chi>在一九六八年的台湾,发生了一件由翻译引发的案件——作家柏杨因漫画"大力水手"中的几句翻译而锒铛入狱。本文结合Lefevere的有关翻译理论对柏杨的翻译以及他获罪原因进行分析,并对有关翻译与意识形态关系的问题进行探讨。通过"大力水手"这一个案研究,我们可以看到,翻译虽然在特定情况下与一定历史时期的意识形态有紧密的关系,但讨论翻译与意识形态的问题,不能简单机械地套用某些翻译理论,而要尽可能多地考虑到多方面的因素,这样才可以对翻译作品及译者有公正客观的评价。<Chi><Eng>There was an incident arising from translation in Taiwan in 1968: a writer named Bo Yang was imprisoned simply because of the wording in his translation of the comic Popeye. This paper analyzes the reason of his imprisonment by applying Lefevere’s translation theory and further discusses the relationship between translation and ideology. Through the analysis of the case of the "Popeye Incident", we may see that, although translation is inseparable from certain ideology at certain historical period, we should not simply apply translation theory mechanically; instead we should take as many factors as possible into consideration and thus we may do justice to the translations as well as the translators.<Eng>

KW - 翻译

KW - 意识形态

KW - "大力水手"

KW - 柏杨

UR - http://www.academia.edu/8190327/%E6%9F%8F%E6%9D%A8%E8%AF%91_%E5%A4%A7%E5%8A%9B%E6%B0%B4%E6%89%8B_%E7%9A%84%E4%B8%AA%E6%A1%88%E5%88%86%E6%9E%90_A_Case_Study_on_Bo_Yang_s_Translation_of_Bud_Sagendorf_s_Comic_Popeye_

UR - http://commons.ln.edu.hk/sw_master/4921

U2 - 10.3969/j.issn.1674-8921.2014.07.011

DO - 10.3969/j.issn.1674-8921.2014.07.011

M3 - Journal Article (refereed)

VL - 2014

SP - 56-61, 78

JO - 当代外语研究 = Contemporary Foreign Languages Studies

JF - 当代外语研究 = Contemporary Foreign Languages Studies

SN - 1674-8921

IS - 7

ER -