沼泽人疑难与历时整体论: The Swampman puzzle and diachronic holism

Research output: Journal PublicationsJournal Article (refereed)

Abstract

如果歷史對于心靈是必要的話,那么前者以何種方式對后者構成約束而使之具備諸如意向性、內容之類的規范性地位?本文通過對沼澤人思想實驗的分析,對這些問題給出一種歷時整體論的獨特解答,即瞬間形成的沼澤人仍具有規范意義上的心靈。歷時整體論既反對包括目的論語義學在內的狹義歷史主義立場,但又不輕視自然主義進化論的解釋作用。本文引入了回顧必然性這一特殊模態概念,并說明在何種意義上它可成為歷時整體論的核心觀念。 How does history constitute a constraint on mind so as to make mind possess such normative statuses such as intentionality and content? This paper yields a unique, diachronically holistic answer to this question via a novel analysis of the Swampman thought experiment. Diachronic holism distinguishes itself from the sort of narrow historicist position represented by teleosemantics while granting no less importance to the explanatory role of evolution.A special modal notion of retrospective necessity is introduced with an eye to explicating the sense in which it serves as the core concept of diachronic holism.
Original languageChinese (Simplified)
Pages (from-to)114-122
Number of pages9
Journal哲学研究
Volume2016
Issue number11
Publication statusPublished - 1 Nov 2016

Cite this

@article{f1a4912f1fbe4ed8b48ee37c8599471b,
title = "沼泽人疑难与历时整体论: The Swampman puzzle and diachronic holism",
abstract = "如果歷史對于心靈是必要的話,那么前者以何種方式對后者構成約束而使之具備諸如意向性、內容之類的規范性地位?本文通過對沼澤人思想實驗的分析,對這些問題給出一種歷時整體論的獨特解答,即瞬間形成的沼澤人仍具有規范意義上的心靈。歷時整體論既反對包括目的論語義學在內的狹義歷史主義立場,但又不輕視自然主義進化論的解釋作用。本文引入了回顧必然性這一特殊模態概念,并說明在何種意義上它可成為歷時整體論的核心觀念。 How does history constitute a constraint on mind so as to make mind possess such normative statuses such as intentionality and content? This paper yields a unique, diachronically holistic answer to this question via a novel analysis of the Swampman thought experiment. Diachronic holism distinguishes itself from the sort of narrow historicist position represented by teleosemantics while granting no less importance to the explanatory role of evolution.A special modal notion of retrospective necessity is introduced with an eye to explicating the sense in which it serves as the core concept of diachronic holism.",
author = "鄭宇健",
year = "2016",
month = "11",
day = "1",
language = "Chinese (Simplified)",
volume = "2016",
pages = "114--122",
journal = "哲学研究",
issn = "1000-0216",
number = "11",

}

沼泽人疑难与历时整体论 : The Swampman puzzle and diachronic holism. / 鄭宇健.

In: 哲学研究, Vol. 2016, No. 11, 01.11.2016, p. 114-122.

Research output: Journal PublicationsJournal Article (refereed)

TY - JOUR

T1 - 沼泽人疑难与历时整体论

T2 - The Swampman puzzle and diachronic holism

AU - 鄭宇健, null

PY - 2016/11/1

Y1 - 2016/11/1

N2 - 如果歷史對于心靈是必要的話,那么前者以何種方式對后者構成約束而使之具備諸如意向性、內容之類的規范性地位?本文通過對沼澤人思想實驗的分析,對這些問題給出一種歷時整體論的獨特解答,即瞬間形成的沼澤人仍具有規范意義上的心靈。歷時整體論既反對包括目的論語義學在內的狹義歷史主義立場,但又不輕視自然主義進化論的解釋作用。本文引入了回顧必然性這一特殊模態概念,并說明在何種意義上它可成為歷時整體論的核心觀念。 How does history constitute a constraint on mind so as to make mind possess such normative statuses such as intentionality and content? This paper yields a unique, diachronically holistic answer to this question via a novel analysis of the Swampman thought experiment. Diachronic holism distinguishes itself from the sort of narrow historicist position represented by teleosemantics while granting no less importance to the explanatory role of evolution.A special modal notion of retrospective necessity is introduced with an eye to explicating the sense in which it serves as the core concept of diachronic holism.

AB - 如果歷史對于心靈是必要的話,那么前者以何種方式對后者構成約束而使之具備諸如意向性、內容之類的規范性地位?本文通過對沼澤人思想實驗的分析,對這些問題給出一種歷時整體論的獨特解答,即瞬間形成的沼澤人仍具有規范意義上的心靈。歷時整體論既反對包括目的論語義學在內的狹義歷史主義立場,但又不輕視自然主義進化論的解釋作用。本文引入了回顧必然性這一特殊模態概念,并說明在何種意義上它可成為歷時整體論的核心觀念。 How does history constitute a constraint on mind so as to make mind possess such normative statuses such as intentionality and content? This paper yields a unique, diachronically holistic answer to this question via a novel analysis of the Swampman thought experiment. Diachronic holism distinguishes itself from the sort of narrow historicist position represented by teleosemantics while granting no less importance to the explanatory role of evolution.A special modal notion of retrospective necessity is introduced with an eye to explicating the sense in which it serves as the core concept of diachronic holism.

UR - http://www.cssn.cn/zhx/zx_kxjszx/201707/t20170730_3595530.shtml

UR - http://commons.ln.edu.hk/sw_master/6111

M3 - Journal Article (refereed)

VL - 2016

SP - 114

EP - 122

JO - 哲学研究

JF - 哲学研究

SN - 1000-0216

IS - 11

ER -