牟宗三先生對「為何道德」的議論初探

An inquiry into Mou Tsung-san's discussion on "why be moral"

    Research output: Journal PublicationsJournal Article (refereed)Researchpeer-review

    Abstract

    「為何道德」(Why be moral?)的問題,是後設倫理學(meta-ethics)的一個主要問題。本文會從英美關於「為何道德」的討論開始,檢視經驗進路的問題及缺憾,而這缺憾又如何逼出形上領域的探討。牟宗三先生認為儒家的道德的形上學,才能貫通形上形下的世界,為道德提供堅實的基礎。他以儒家的本心本性說明道德的普遍必然性,以至使人「無可逃於天地之間」。本文除了闡述此點外,更指出道德哲學與形上學在何種意義下,有着緊密的關聯。 The question of "Why Be Moral" is an important issue in meta-ethics. In this article I will start with the examination of the empirical approach to this question and its difficulties. I will then show that how the discussion is inevitably led to the sphere of metaphysics. Mou Tsung-san argued that only the Moral Metaphysics of Confucianism can provide a substantial ground for morality. He explained the universality and necessity of morals by the Confucian idea of original heart-mind and original nature. Apart from elaborating Mou's view, I also expound that in what sense there is a close relation between moral philosophy and metaphysics.
    Original languageChinese (Traditional)
    Pages (from-to)237-256
    Number of pages20
    Journal鵝湖學誌 = Legein Semi-annual Journal
    Issue number56
    Publication statusPublished - 1 Jun 2016

    Cite this

    @article{e29e2e82f1154a65a128dd7d112ac1c3,
    title = "牟宗三先生對「為何道德」的議論初探: An inquiry into Mou Tsung-san's discussion on {"}why be moral{"}",
    abstract = "「為何道德」(Why be moral?)的問題,是後設倫理學(meta-ethics)的一個主要問題。本文會從英美關於「為何道德」的討論開始,檢視經驗進路的問題及缺憾,而這缺憾又如何逼出形上領域的探討。牟宗三先生認為儒家的道德的形上學,才能貫通形上形下的世界,為道德提供堅實的基礎。他以儒家的本心本性說明道德的普遍必然性,以至使人「無可逃於天地之間」。本文除了闡述此點外,更指出道德哲學與形上學在何種意義下,有着緊密的關聯。 The question of {"}Why Be Moral{"} is an important issue in meta-ethics. In this article I will start with the examination of the empirical approach to this question and its difficulties. I will then show that how the discussion is inevitably led to the sphere of metaphysics. Mou Tsung-san argued that only the Moral Metaphysics of Confucianism can provide a substantial ground for morality. He explained the universality and necessity of morals by the Confucian idea of original heart-mind and original nature. Apart from elaborating Mou's view, I also expound that in what sense there is a close relation between moral philosophy and metaphysics.",
    author = "黃慧英",
    year = "2016",
    month = "6",
    day = "1",
    language = "Chinese (Traditional)",
    pages = "237--256",
    journal = "鵝湖學誌 = Legein Semi-annual Journal",
    issn = "1021-3732",
    number = "56",

    }

    牟宗三先生對「為何道德」的議論初探 : An inquiry into Mou Tsung-san's discussion on "why be moral". / 黃慧英.

    In: 鵝湖學誌 = Legein Semi-annual Journal, No. 56, 01.06.2016, p. 237-256.

    Research output: Journal PublicationsJournal Article (refereed)Researchpeer-review

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - 牟宗三先生對「為何道德」的議論初探

    T2 - An inquiry into Mou Tsung-san's discussion on "why be moral"

    AU - 黃慧英, null

    PY - 2016/6/1

    Y1 - 2016/6/1

    N2 - 「為何道德」(Why be moral?)的問題,是後設倫理學(meta-ethics)的一個主要問題。本文會從英美關於「為何道德」的討論開始,檢視經驗進路的問題及缺憾,而這缺憾又如何逼出形上領域的探討。牟宗三先生認為儒家的道德的形上學,才能貫通形上形下的世界,為道德提供堅實的基礎。他以儒家的本心本性說明道德的普遍必然性,以至使人「無可逃於天地之間」。本文除了闡述此點外,更指出道德哲學與形上學在何種意義下,有着緊密的關聯。 The question of "Why Be Moral" is an important issue in meta-ethics. In this article I will start with the examination of the empirical approach to this question and its difficulties. I will then show that how the discussion is inevitably led to the sphere of metaphysics. Mou Tsung-san argued that only the Moral Metaphysics of Confucianism can provide a substantial ground for morality. He explained the universality and necessity of morals by the Confucian idea of original heart-mind and original nature. Apart from elaborating Mou's view, I also expound that in what sense there is a close relation between moral philosophy and metaphysics.

    AB - 「為何道德」(Why be moral?)的問題,是後設倫理學(meta-ethics)的一個主要問題。本文會從英美關於「為何道德」的討論開始,檢視經驗進路的問題及缺憾,而這缺憾又如何逼出形上領域的探討。牟宗三先生認為儒家的道德的形上學,才能貫通形上形下的世界,為道德提供堅實的基礎。他以儒家的本心本性說明道德的普遍必然性,以至使人「無可逃於天地之間」。本文除了闡述此點外,更指出道德哲學與形上學在何種意義下,有着緊密的關聯。 The question of "Why Be Moral" is an important issue in meta-ethics. In this article I will start with the examination of the empirical approach to this question and its difficulties. I will then show that how the discussion is inevitably led to the sphere of metaphysics. Mou Tsung-san argued that only the Moral Metaphysics of Confucianism can provide a substantial ground for morality. He explained the universality and necessity of morals by the Confucian idea of original heart-mind and original nature. Apart from elaborating Mou's view, I also expound that in what sense there is a close relation between moral philosophy and metaphysics.

    UR - http://www.airitilibrary.com/Publication/alDetailedMesh?docid=10213732-201606-201611020009-201611020009-237-256

    UR - http://commons.ln.edu.hk/sw_master/5378

    M3 - Journal Article (refereed)

    SP - 237

    EP - 256

    JO - 鵝湖學誌 = Legein Semi-annual Journal

    JF - 鵝湖學誌 = Legein Semi-annual Journal

    SN - 1021-3732

    IS - 56

    ER -