A polysystemist’s response to prescriptive cultural relativism and postcolonialism

Nam Fung CHANG

Research output: Journal PublicationsJournal Article (refereed)

2 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Translation studies and other disciplines in the humanities have become increasingly politicized as scholars act on the presumption that the dominance of Western theories is the result of power differentials rather than academic merit. This postcolonialist mindset is based on the claim that cultures are equally valid, but there are objective and cross-culturally intersubjective standards for comparing certain aspects of cultures. The problems with such prescriptive cultural relativism are that the nation-state is regarded as the only legitimate unit of culture, that national differences are overemphasized, and that an “is” is turned into an “ought.” Built on these misconceptions, postcolonialism challenges the political establishment in central countries but serves as an excuse to suppress the demand for progress from peripheral sectors in peripheral cultures. The attempt to export postcolonialism, a culture-specific theory, to the whole world is thus itself a colonialist act.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)133-154
Number of pages22
JournalAcross Languages and Cultures
Volume18
Issue number1
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1 Jun 2017

Fingerprint

cultural relativism
national culture
nation state
Postcolonialism
Cultural Relativism
Prescriptive
demand

Cite this

@article{2d9ad0960fb64f4eae5c4b964a4613c3,
title = "A polysystemist’s response to prescriptive cultural relativism and postcolonialism",
abstract = "Translation studies and other disciplines in the humanities have become increasingly politicized as scholars act on the presumption that the dominance of Western theories is the result of power differentials rather than academic merit. This postcolonialist mindset is based on the claim that cultures are equally valid, but there are objective and cross-culturally intersubjective standards for comparing certain aspects of cultures. The problems with such prescriptive cultural relativism are that the nation-state is regarded as the only legitimate unit of culture, that national differences are overemphasized, and that an “is” is turned into an “ought.” Built on these misconceptions, postcolonialism challenges the political establishment in central countries but serves as an excuse to suppress the demand for progress from peripheral sectors in peripheral cultures. The attempt to export postcolonialism, a culture-specific theory, to the whole world is thus itself a colonialist act.",
author = "CHANG, {Nam Fung}",
year = "2017",
month = "6",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1556/084.2017.18.1.6",
language = "English",
volume = "18",
pages = "133--154",
journal = "Across Languages and Cultures",
issn = "1585-1923",
publisher = "Akademiai Kiado",
number = "1",

}

A polysystemist’s response to prescriptive cultural relativism and postcolonialism. / CHANG, Nam Fung.

In: Across Languages and Cultures, Vol. 18, No. 1, 01.06.2017, p. 133-154.

Research output: Journal PublicationsJournal Article (refereed)

TY - JOUR

T1 - A polysystemist’s response to prescriptive cultural relativism and postcolonialism

AU - CHANG, Nam Fung

PY - 2017/6/1

Y1 - 2017/6/1

N2 - Translation studies and other disciplines in the humanities have become increasingly politicized as scholars act on the presumption that the dominance of Western theories is the result of power differentials rather than academic merit. This postcolonialist mindset is based on the claim that cultures are equally valid, but there are objective and cross-culturally intersubjective standards for comparing certain aspects of cultures. The problems with such prescriptive cultural relativism are that the nation-state is regarded as the only legitimate unit of culture, that national differences are overemphasized, and that an “is” is turned into an “ought.” Built on these misconceptions, postcolonialism challenges the political establishment in central countries but serves as an excuse to suppress the demand for progress from peripheral sectors in peripheral cultures. The attempt to export postcolonialism, a culture-specific theory, to the whole world is thus itself a colonialist act.

AB - Translation studies and other disciplines in the humanities have become increasingly politicized as scholars act on the presumption that the dominance of Western theories is the result of power differentials rather than academic merit. This postcolonialist mindset is based on the claim that cultures are equally valid, but there are objective and cross-culturally intersubjective standards for comparing certain aspects of cultures. The problems with such prescriptive cultural relativism are that the nation-state is regarded as the only legitimate unit of culture, that national differences are overemphasized, and that an “is” is turned into an “ought.” Built on these misconceptions, postcolonialism challenges the political establishment in central countries but serves as an excuse to suppress the demand for progress from peripheral sectors in peripheral cultures. The attempt to export postcolonialism, a culture-specific theory, to the whole world is thus itself a colonialist act.

UR - http://commons.ln.edu.hk/sw_master/6518

U2 - 10.1556/084.2017.18.1.6

DO - 10.1556/084.2017.18.1.6

M3 - Journal Article (refereed)

VL - 18

SP - 133

EP - 154

JO - Across Languages and Cultures

JF - Across Languages and Cultures

SN - 1585-1923

IS - 1

ER -