Apologies for Historical Injustices and Psychological Responses to Them

Research output: Other Conference ContributionsConference Paper (other)Other Conference Paperpeer-review

Abstract

Apologies have entered the political arena as one of policy interventions devised to address legacies of various historical injustices. Their utility has been empirically examined in the areas of transitional justice and social psychology. However, apologies have been often treated indiscriminately, although their contents may vary. This paper examines psychological responses to major parts of apologies for historical injustices. Based on the transformative theory of justice, it hypothesizes that those parts of apologies that symbolize the transformative status of former perpetrators would be more likely to increase the perception of justice than other components of apologies. To examine the hypotheses, the paper focuses on Japan's apologies for historical injustices committed in Korea in 1910-45. It is based on the text analysis of apologies issued by Japanese government and its officials . In total, 85 apologies were coded into 16 categories. Four most frequent categories were then selected and put to an experimental test to examine their effects on psychological responses and justice perceptions. The between-group experiment manipulated apologies that expressed acceptance of responsibility, admission of wrongdoing, and acknowledgment of victims' suffering, which were contrasted with denial. The experiment was administered via Qualtrics panel of 210 Koreans. The results show positive effects of these apologies on emotions and the perceptions of historical justice.
Original languageEnglish
Publication statusPublished - 31 May 2019
EventLaw and Society Association 2019 Annual Meeting: Dignity - Hyatt Regency Washington on Capitol Hill, Washington, United States
Duration: 30 May 20192 Jun 2019
https://www.lawandsociety.org/WashingtonDC2019/Washington2019.html

Conference

ConferenceLaw and Society Association 2019 Annual Meeting
CountryUnited States
CityWashington
Period30/05/192/06/19
OtherAnnual Meeting on Law and Society
Internet address

Fingerprint

justice
text analysis
experiment
social psychology
Korea
emotion
acceptance
Japan
responsibility
Group

Cite this

DAVID, R., & YEUNG, W. L. V. (2019). Apologies for Historical Injustices and Psychological Responses to Them. Paper presented at Law and Society Association 2019 Annual Meeting, Washington, United States.
DAVID, Roman ; YEUNG, Wai Lan, Victoria. / Apologies for Historical Injustices and Psychological Responses to Them. Paper presented at Law and Society Association 2019 Annual Meeting, Washington, United States.
@conference{f69e71cef4e7422baa7d8954c1dbc9a0,
title = "Apologies for Historical Injustices and Psychological Responses to Them",
abstract = "Apologies have entered the political arena as one of policy interventions devised to address legacies of various historical injustices. Their utility has been empirically examined in the areas of transitional justice and social psychology. However, apologies have been often treated indiscriminately, although their contents may vary. This paper examines psychological responses to major parts of apologies for historical injustices. Based on the transformative theory of justice, it hypothesizes that those parts of apologies that symbolize the transformative status of former perpetrators would be more likely to increase the perception of justice than other components of apologies. To examine the hypotheses, the paper focuses on Japan's apologies for historical injustices committed in Korea in 1910-45. It is based on the text analysis of apologies issued by Japanese government and its officials . In total, 85 apologies were coded into 16 categories. Four most frequent categories were then selected and put to an experimental test to examine their effects on psychological responses and justice perceptions. The between-group experiment manipulated apologies that expressed acceptance of responsibility, admission of wrongdoing, and acknowledgment of victims' suffering, which were contrasted with denial. The experiment was administered via Qualtrics panel of 210 Koreans. The results show positive effects of these apologies on emotions and the perceptions of historical justice.",
author = "Roman DAVID and YEUNG, {Wai Lan, Victoria}",
year = "2019",
month = "5",
day = "31",
language = "English",
note = "Law and Society Association 2019 Annual Meeting : Dignity ; Conference date: 30-05-2019 Through 02-06-2019",
url = "https://www.lawandsociety.org/WashingtonDC2019/Washington2019.html",

}

DAVID, R & YEUNG, WLV 2019, 'Apologies for Historical Injustices and Psychological Responses to Them' Paper presented at Law and Society Association 2019 Annual Meeting, Washington, United States, 30/05/19 - 2/06/19, .

Apologies for Historical Injustices and Psychological Responses to Them. / DAVID, Roman; YEUNG, Wai Lan, Victoria.

2019. Paper presented at Law and Society Association 2019 Annual Meeting, Washington, United States.

Research output: Other Conference ContributionsConference Paper (other)Other Conference Paperpeer-review

TY - CONF

T1 - Apologies for Historical Injustices and Psychological Responses to Them

AU - DAVID, Roman

AU - YEUNG, Wai Lan, Victoria

PY - 2019/5/31

Y1 - 2019/5/31

N2 - Apologies have entered the political arena as one of policy interventions devised to address legacies of various historical injustices. Their utility has been empirically examined in the areas of transitional justice and social psychology. However, apologies have been often treated indiscriminately, although their contents may vary. This paper examines psychological responses to major parts of apologies for historical injustices. Based on the transformative theory of justice, it hypothesizes that those parts of apologies that symbolize the transformative status of former perpetrators would be more likely to increase the perception of justice than other components of apologies. To examine the hypotheses, the paper focuses on Japan's apologies for historical injustices committed in Korea in 1910-45. It is based on the text analysis of apologies issued by Japanese government and its officials . In total, 85 apologies were coded into 16 categories. Four most frequent categories were then selected and put to an experimental test to examine their effects on psychological responses and justice perceptions. The between-group experiment manipulated apologies that expressed acceptance of responsibility, admission of wrongdoing, and acknowledgment of victims' suffering, which were contrasted with denial. The experiment was administered via Qualtrics panel of 210 Koreans. The results show positive effects of these apologies on emotions and the perceptions of historical justice.

AB - Apologies have entered the political arena as one of policy interventions devised to address legacies of various historical injustices. Their utility has been empirically examined in the areas of transitional justice and social psychology. However, apologies have been often treated indiscriminately, although their contents may vary. This paper examines psychological responses to major parts of apologies for historical injustices. Based on the transformative theory of justice, it hypothesizes that those parts of apologies that symbolize the transformative status of former perpetrators would be more likely to increase the perception of justice than other components of apologies. To examine the hypotheses, the paper focuses on Japan's apologies for historical injustices committed in Korea in 1910-45. It is based on the text analysis of apologies issued by Japanese government and its officials . In total, 85 apologies were coded into 16 categories. Four most frequent categories were then selected and put to an experimental test to examine their effects on psychological responses and justice perceptions. The between-group experiment manipulated apologies that expressed acceptance of responsibility, admission of wrongdoing, and acknowledgment of victims' suffering, which were contrasted with denial. The experiment was administered via Qualtrics panel of 210 Koreans. The results show positive effects of these apologies on emotions and the perceptions of historical justice.

M3 - Conference Paper (other)

ER -

DAVID R, YEUNG WLV. Apologies for Historical Injustices and Psychological Responses to Them. 2019. Paper presented at Law and Society Association 2019 Annual Meeting, Washington, United States.