Competition policy under laissez-faireism : market power and its treatment in Hong Kong

Kwan Yiu, Edward CHEN, Ping LIN

Research output: Journal PublicationsJournal Article (refereed)

7 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

The paper describes the current competition policy framework in Hong Kong: how it came into existence, what business practices are prohibited, and how the enforcement system works. Recent cases in the telecommunications industry are used to illustrate the sectoral approach, a unique feature of Hong Kong's competition policy. We argue that a sectoral approach faces two fundamental drawbacks. First, due to having different "rules of the game'' for different sectors, the allocation of resources may be distorted in the long run. Second, since the relevant regulatory agencies perform dual roles both as competition policy enforcer and as traditional regulator of natural monopolies, the impartiality of their competition decisions may not be credibly conveyed to the public. We also address other specific problems associated with the sectoral approach, such as the exclusion of structural issues, narrow coverage of sectors, and the lack of public enforcement. We conclude that an overall competition law can better promote competition and economic efficiency in Hong Kong.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)145-166
Number of pages22
JournalReview of Industrial Organization
Volume21
Issue number2
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1 Sep 2002

Fingerprint

Telecommunication industry
Hong Kong
Competition policy
Market power
Economics
Industry
Telecommunications industry
Economic efficiency
Enforcement
Business practices
Resources
Natural monopoly
Exclusion
Public enforcement
Competition law

Bibliographical note

Paper presented at the Workshop on Treament of Market Power in East Asian Economies, Jun, 2001, Taipei, Taiwan.

Keywords

  • Competition policy
  • Laissez faire
  • Sectoral approach

Cite this

@article{e6b1161ebb534d68988b3a7f7e199ff3,
title = "Competition policy under laissez-faireism : market power and its treatment in Hong Kong",
abstract = "The paper describes the current competition policy framework in Hong Kong: how it came into existence, what business practices are prohibited, and how the enforcement system works. Recent cases in the telecommunications industry are used to illustrate the sectoral approach, a unique feature of Hong Kong's competition policy. We argue that a sectoral approach faces two fundamental drawbacks. First, due to having different {"}rules of the game'' for different sectors, the allocation of resources may be distorted in the long run. Second, since the relevant regulatory agencies perform dual roles both as competition policy enforcer and as traditional regulator of natural monopolies, the impartiality of their competition decisions may not be credibly conveyed to the public. We also address other specific problems associated with the sectoral approach, such as the exclusion of structural issues, narrow coverage of sectors, and the lack of public enforcement. We conclude that an overall competition law can better promote competition and economic efficiency in Hong Kong.",
keywords = "Competition policy, Laissez faire, Sectoral approach",
author = "CHEN, {Kwan Yiu, Edward} and Ping LIN",
note = "Paper presented at the Workshop on Treament of Market Power in East Asian Economies, Jun, 2001, Taipei, Taiwan.",
year = "2002",
month = "9",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1023/A:1019621426648",
language = "English",
volume = "21",
pages = "145--166",
journal = "Review of Industrial Organization",
issn = "0889-938X",
publisher = "Springer Netherlands",
number = "2",

}

Competition policy under laissez-faireism : market power and its treatment in Hong Kong. / CHEN, Kwan Yiu, Edward; LIN, Ping.

In: Review of Industrial Organization, Vol. 21, No. 2, 01.09.2002, p. 145-166.

Research output: Journal PublicationsJournal Article (refereed)

TY - JOUR

T1 - Competition policy under laissez-faireism : market power and its treatment in Hong Kong

AU - CHEN, Kwan Yiu, Edward

AU - LIN, Ping

N1 - Paper presented at the Workshop on Treament of Market Power in East Asian Economies, Jun, 2001, Taipei, Taiwan.

PY - 2002/9/1

Y1 - 2002/9/1

N2 - The paper describes the current competition policy framework in Hong Kong: how it came into existence, what business practices are prohibited, and how the enforcement system works. Recent cases in the telecommunications industry are used to illustrate the sectoral approach, a unique feature of Hong Kong's competition policy. We argue that a sectoral approach faces two fundamental drawbacks. First, due to having different "rules of the game'' for different sectors, the allocation of resources may be distorted in the long run. Second, since the relevant regulatory agencies perform dual roles both as competition policy enforcer and as traditional regulator of natural monopolies, the impartiality of their competition decisions may not be credibly conveyed to the public. We also address other specific problems associated with the sectoral approach, such as the exclusion of structural issues, narrow coverage of sectors, and the lack of public enforcement. We conclude that an overall competition law can better promote competition and economic efficiency in Hong Kong.

AB - The paper describes the current competition policy framework in Hong Kong: how it came into existence, what business practices are prohibited, and how the enforcement system works. Recent cases in the telecommunications industry are used to illustrate the sectoral approach, a unique feature of Hong Kong's competition policy. We argue that a sectoral approach faces two fundamental drawbacks. First, due to having different "rules of the game'' for different sectors, the allocation of resources may be distorted in the long run. Second, since the relevant regulatory agencies perform dual roles both as competition policy enforcer and as traditional regulator of natural monopolies, the impartiality of their competition decisions may not be credibly conveyed to the public. We also address other specific problems associated with the sectoral approach, such as the exclusion of structural issues, narrow coverage of sectors, and the lack of public enforcement. We conclude that an overall competition law can better promote competition and economic efficiency in Hong Kong.

KW - Competition policy

KW - Laissez faire

KW - Sectoral approach

UR - http://commons.ln.edu.hk/sw_master/2034

U2 - 10.1023/A:1019621426648

DO - 10.1023/A:1019621426648

M3 - Journal Article (refereed)

VL - 21

SP - 145

EP - 166

JO - Review of Industrial Organization

JF - Review of Industrial Organization

SN - 0889-938X

IS - 2

ER -