Gangs in the markets : network-based cognition in China's futures industry

Leung Sea, Lucia SIU

Research output: Journal PublicationsJournal Article (refereed)Researchpeer-review

2 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Gangs in traditional Chinese society often arise from the lower social strata, where wealth, social status and kinship are inadequate to protect people from hostile or adverse environments. It is intriguing that modern futures investors in China, as owners of capital, would form a social structure that partially resembles the marginal groups of society. This paper portrays different social connectivity within the investor community of China’s commodity futures markets, including organized battle team, proximity cliques, capital factions based on geographical or industrial affiliations, and charismatic leaders. It also explores how a capital faction’s leadership, origins of capital and geographical location helps to shape some of its investment style and risk-taking characteristics. Based on empirical ethnographic fieldwork in 2005 and documentary research on China’s futures markets, the author argues that the textbook definitions of “hedgers”, “speculators”, “rational individuals” and “price discovery” are far from adequate to represent China’s markets. In reality the markets are made up by flexible socioeconomic aggregates continually interacting with each other, whose characteristics are shaped by social connectivity and background affiliation. Price movements are a collective result of the purposeful actions of the market people themselves, not some latent information waiting to be “discovered” outside the human world.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)371-389
Number of pages19
JournalInternational Journal of China Studies
Volume1
Issue number2
Publication statusPublished - 1 Oct 2010

Fingerprint

cognition
futures market
China
industry
faction
market
investor
social stratum
kinship
social structure
textbook
commodity
social status
leadership
leader
community
Group
Society

Cite this

@article{9527873ff11f49c3a1e06651f9a83306,
title = "Gangs in the markets : network-based cognition in China's futures industry",
abstract = "Gangs in traditional Chinese society often arise from the lower social strata, where wealth, social status and kinship are inadequate to protect people from hostile or adverse environments. It is intriguing that modern futures investors in China, as owners of capital, would form a social structure that partially resembles the marginal groups of society. This paper portrays different social connectivity within the investor community of China’s commodity futures markets, including organized battle team, proximity cliques, capital factions based on geographical or industrial affiliations, and charismatic leaders. It also explores how a capital faction’s leadership, origins of capital and geographical location helps to shape some of its investment style and risk-taking characteristics. Based on empirical ethnographic fieldwork in 2005 and documentary research on China’s futures markets, the author argues that the textbook definitions of “hedgers”, “speculators”, “rational individuals” and “price discovery” are far from adequate to represent China’s markets. In reality the markets are made up by flexible socioeconomic aggregates continually interacting with each other, whose characteristics are shaped by social connectivity and background affiliation. Price movements are a collective result of the purposeful actions of the market people themselves, not some latent information waiting to be “discovered” outside the human world.",
author = "SIU, {Leung Sea, Lucia}",
year = "2010",
month = "10",
day = "1",
language = "English",
volume = "1",
pages = "371--389",
journal = "International Journal of China Studies",
issn = "2180-3250",
publisher = "Institute of China Studies, University of Malaya",
number = "2",

}

Gangs in the markets : network-based cognition in China's futures industry. / SIU, Leung Sea, Lucia.

In: International Journal of China Studies, Vol. 1, No. 2, 01.10.2010, p. 371-389.

Research output: Journal PublicationsJournal Article (refereed)Researchpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Gangs in the markets : network-based cognition in China's futures industry

AU - SIU, Leung Sea, Lucia

PY - 2010/10/1

Y1 - 2010/10/1

N2 - Gangs in traditional Chinese society often arise from the lower social strata, where wealth, social status and kinship are inadequate to protect people from hostile or adverse environments. It is intriguing that modern futures investors in China, as owners of capital, would form a social structure that partially resembles the marginal groups of society. This paper portrays different social connectivity within the investor community of China’s commodity futures markets, including organized battle team, proximity cliques, capital factions based on geographical or industrial affiliations, and charismatic leaders. It also explores how a capital faction’s leadership, origins of capital and geographical location helps to shape some of its investment style and risk-taking characteristics. Based on empirical ethnographic fieldwork in 2005 and documentary research on China’s futures markets, the author argues that the textbook definitions of “hedgers”, “speculators”, “rational individuals” and “price discovery” are far from adequate to represent China’s markets. In reality the markets are made up by flexible socioeconomic aggregates continually interacting with each other, whose characteristics are shaped by social connectivity and background affiliation. Price movements are a collective result of the purposeful actions of the market people themselves, not some latent information waiting to be “discovered” outside the human world.

AB - Gangs in traditional Chinese society often arise from the lower social strata, where wealth, social status and kinship are inadequate to protect people from hostile or adverse environments. It is intriguing that modern futures investors in China, as owners of capital, would form a social structure that partially resembles the marginal groups of society. This paper portrays different social connectivity within the investor community of China’s commodity futures markets, including organized battle team, proximity cliques, capital factions based on geographical or industrial affiliations, and charismatic leaders. It also explores how a capital faction’s leadership, origins of capital and geographical location helps to shape some of its investment style and risk-taking characteristics. Based on empirical ethnographic fieldwork in 2005 and documentary research on China’s futures markets, the author argues that the textbook definitions of “hedgers”, “speculators”, “rational individuals” and “price discovery” are far from adequate to represent China’s markets. In reality the markets are made up by flexible socioeconomic aggregates continually interacting with each other, whose characteristics are shaped by social connectivity and background affiliation. Price movements are a collective result of the purposeful actions of the market people themselves, not some latent information waiting to be “discovered” outside the human world.

UR - http://commons.ln.edu.hk/sw_master/816

M3 - Journal Article (refereed)

VL - 1

SP - 371

EP - 389

JO - International Journal of China Studies

JF - International Journal of China Studies

SN - 2180-3250

IS - 2

ER -