Good leadership : a mirage in the desert?

Anders ÖRTENBLAD, Fok Loi, Jacky HONG, Robin Stanley SNELL

    Research output: Journal PublicationsJournal Article (refereed)Researchpeer-review

    2 Citations (Scopus)

    Abstract

    Whether those who lead us are practicing good or bad leadership, or anything in between, is a matter of ongoing controversy that can be viewed from multiple perspectives. Even if such controversy is inherently unresolvable, there is still good reason to keep on asking ourselves whether providing leadership education or development programmes actually has any positive effects. Are such programmes worth the effort? Should they be rede- signed to better foster critical thinking? Should they be replaced by arrangements that emphasize leadership practice in ‘natural’ or ‘field’ settings, where people are encouraged to find their own ways to develop into good leaders? Should we abandon efforts to provide for the development of leadership attributes and instead focus on identifying ‘naturally born good leaders’ and empowering these outstanding people? Or should we rethink and reframe our conceptions of the role/position of leadership as something special, and transform leadership into more accessible and less challenging forms that more people can handle? In this special issue, we do not seek to solve these issues once-and-for-all. Instead, we aim to broaden the debates by offering some less common perspectives on how bad leadership might be averted and how good leadership might be fostered or enabled. The five articles in this special issue are the main inputs. In this introduction to the special issue, our aim to provide a conceptual map and place the contributions made by the five articles onto this map.
    Original languageEnglish
    Pages (from-to)349-357
    Number of pages9
    JournalHuman Resource Development International
    Volume19
    Issue number5
    DOIs
    Publication statusPublished - 1 Jan 2016

    Fingerprint

    Multiple perspectives
    Critical thinking
    OR education
    Conception

    Cite this

    ÖRTENBLAD, Anders ; HONG, Fok Loi, Jacky ; SNELL, Robin Stanley. / Good leadership : a mirage in the desert?. In: Human Resource Development International. 2016 ; Vol. 19, No. 5. pp. 349-357.
    @article{401e053c052f40ba964d20e99aae69d1,
    title = "Good leadership : a mirage in the desert?",
    abstract = "Whether those who lead us are practicing good or bad leadership, or anything in between, is a matter of ongoing controversy that can be viewed from multiple perspectives. Even if such controversy is inherently unresolvable, there is still good reason to keep on asking ourselves whether providing leadership education or development programmes actually has any positive effects. Are such programmes worth the effort? Should they be rede- signed to better foster critical thinking? Should they be replaced by arrangements that emphasize leadership practice in ‘natural’ or ‘field’ settings, where people are encouraged to find their own ways to develop into good leaders? Should we abandon efforts to provide for the development of leadership attributes and instead focus on identifying ‘naturally born good leaders’ and empowering these outstanding people? Or should we rethink and reframe our conceptions of the role/position of leadership as something special, and transform leadership into more accessible and less challenging forms that more people can handle? In this special issue, we do not seek to solve these issues once-and-for-all. Instead, we aim to broaden the debates by offering some less common perspectives on how bad leadership might be averted and how good leadership might be fostered or enabled. The five articles in this special issue are the main inputs. In this introduction to the special issue, our aim to provide a conceptual map and place the contributions made by the five articles onto this map.",
    author = "Anders {\"O}RTENBLAD and HONG, {Fok Loi, Jacky} and SNELL, {Robin Stanley}",
    year = "2016",
    month = "1",
    day = "1",
    doi = "10.1080/13678868.2016.1216736",
    language = "English",
    volume = "19",
    pages = "349--357",
    journal = "Human Resource Development International",
    issn = "1367-8868",
    publisher = "Taylor and Francis Ltd.",
    number = "5",

    }

    Good leadership : a mirage in the desert? / ÖRTENBLAD, Anders; HONG, Fok Loi, Jacky; SNELL, Robin Stanley.

    In: Human Resource Development International, Vol. 19, No. 5, 01.01.2016, p. 349-357.

    Research output: Journal PublicationsJournal Article (refereed)Researchpeer-review

    TY - JOUR

    T1 - Good leadership : a mirage in the desert?

    AU - ÖRTENBLAD, Anders

    AU - HONG, Fok Loi, Jacky

    AU - SNELL, Robin Stanley

    PY - 2016/1/1

    Y1 - 2016/1/1

    N2 - Whether those who lead us are practicing good or bad leadership, or anything in between, is a matter of ongoing controversy that can be viewed from multiple perspectives. Even if such controversy is inherently unresolvable, there is still good reason to keep on asking ourselves whether providing leadership education or development programmes actually has any positive effects. Are such programmes worth the effort? Should they be rede- signed to better foster critical thinking? Should they be replaced by arrangements that emphasize leadership practice in ‘natural’ or ‘field’ settings, where people are encouraged to find their own ways to develop into good leaders? Should we abandon efforts to provide for the development of leadership attributes and instead focus on identifying ‘naturally born good leaders’ and empowering these outstanding people? Or should we rethink and reframe our conceptions of the role/position of leadership as something special, and transform leadership into more accessible and less challenging forms that more people can handle? In this special issue, we do not seek to solve these issues once-and-for-all. Instead, we aim to broaden the debates by offering some less common perspectives on how bad leadership might be averted and how good leadership might be fostered or enabled. The five articles in this special issue are the main inputs. In this introduction to the special issue, our aim to provide a conceptual map and place the contributions made by the five articles onto this map.

    AB - Whether those who lead us are practicing good or bad leadership, or anything in between, is a matter of ongoing controversy that can be viewed from multiple perspectives. Even if such controversy is inherently unresolvable, there is still good reason to keep on asking ourselves whether providing leadership education or development programmes actually has any positive effects. Are such programmes worth the effort? Should they be rede- signed to better foster critical thinking? Should they be replaced by arrangements that emphasize leadership practice in ‘natural’ or ‘field’ settings, where people are encouraged to find their own ways to develop into good leaders? Should we abandon efforts to provide for the development of leadership attributes and instead focus on identifying ‘naturally born good leaders’ and empowering these outstanding people? Or should we rethink and reframe our conceptions of the role/position of leadership as something special, and transform leadership into more accessible and less challenging forms that more people can handle? In this special issue, we do not seek to solve these issues once-and-for-all. Instead, we aim to broaden the debates by offering some less common perspectives on how bad leadership might be averted and how good leadership might be fostered or enabled. The five articles in this special issue are the main inputs. In this introduction to the special issue, our aim to provide a conceptual map and place the contributions made by the five articles onto this map.

    UR - http://commons.ln.edu.hk/sw_master/5445

    U2 - 10.1080/13678868.2016.1216736

    DO - 10.1080/13678868.2016.1216736

    M3 - Journal Article (refereed)

    VL - 19

    SP - 349

    EP - 357

    JO - Human Resource Development International

    JF - Human Resource Development International

    SN - 1367-8868

    IS - 5

    ER -