Market integration in China, AD 960-1644

Research output: Book Chapters | Papers in Conference ProceedingsBook ChapterResearchpeer-review

Abstract

This chapter explores the market performance in pre-industrial China by comparing food prices and per capita money stocks in the Song (AD 960 1279) and Ming dynasties (AD 1368-1644). As recent economic research seems to show, macro-level stability based on increasing market performance is a necessary, although not sufficient, condition for pre-industrial growth. This increase in a pre-industrial economy would reduce the price volatility caused by harvest failures and promote specialization of production. All this advances agricultural productivity and improves the living standard of farmers and consumers alike. Other studies in this book have already identified a few contributing factors that help to explain market performance (i.e. lower conditional price volatility): trade, farming technology (increasing output), storage, consumption (if people started to diversify their consumption), institutions/government and monetary developments (which affect income and prices). However, in this chapter, because of the large monetary changes that occurred in China in the period under study, I focus my analysis on long-term changes in money stocks from the Song to the Ming dynasties to define and explain the performance of food markets in these nearly seven centuries.

In the following, I first present a survey of long-term changes in grain prices in late imperial China. The survey clearly indicates the existence of two different price regimes, separated by the Mongol conquest of China in the late thirteenth century and the establishment of the Ming dynasty in 1368. The average level of food prices measured in silver remained much lower during the sixteenth century when the population grew and the market expanded. However, documenting rises and/or declines in prices docs not itself explain increasing or decreasing market integration. To explain the century-long deflation and its impact on trade, I further compare the money supply between the Song and Ming eras. This comparison points to a huge decline in money stocks between the eleventh and sixteenth centuries at both aggregate and per capita levels, and it was this decline that was chiefly responsible for the lower price level in the sixteenth century.

The contraction or expansion of the market in the traditional Chinese economy essentially determines the monetary needs. I his chapter challenges the current wisdom about the transition towards a silver economy in the Ming era, which often assumes a deepening in the monetization of the economy and an enormous increase in the money supply during the transition, by providing a comprehensive measurement of the sharp decline in the money stock after the Ming dynasty was founded. The paucity of hard currencies was still felt even when China began to import silver from overseas trade. I argue that it was the anti-market policies implemented by the early Ming court (1368-1450) that substantially converted the whole economy into a barter economy and thus diminished the volume of hard currencies in circulation. The prevalence of payment-in-kind and counterfeit coins increased transaction costs and produced difficulties for long-distance trade. To test how currency affects market performance, I examine in detail the economic instability in the economy of the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries, an instability caused by the insufficient supply of hard currencies. Although this is the first time in the literature of Chinese economic history that an attempt has been made to explicitly relate long-term price movements to the quantity of money, the following analysis docs successfully demonstrate the important role that the money supply performed. In sum, the comparison reveals a regression in market integration from the collapse of the Song dynasty in AD 1279 through the Ming period.
Original languageEnglish
Title of host publicationA history of market performance : from ancient Babylonia to the modern world
EditorsR. J. VAN DER SPEK, Bas VAN LEEUWEN, Jan Luiten VAN ZANDEN
Place of PublicationOxon
PublisherRoutledge
Chapter12
Pages308-338
Number of pages31
ISBN (Electronic)9781315852379
ISBN (Print)9780415635448
Publication statusPublished - 21 Aug 2014
Externally publishedYes

Publication series

NameRoutledge explorations in economic history
PublisherRoutledge
Number68

Fingerprint

Market integration
China
Currency
Market performance
Money supply
Food prices
Price volatility
Counterfeit
Import
Transaction costs
Farming
Contraction
Payment
Farmers
Agricultural productivity
Income
Government
Price level
Industrial growth
Wisdom

Cite this

LIU, G. (2014). Market integration in China, AD 960-1644. In R. J. VAN DER SPEK, B. VAN LEEUWEN, & J. L. VAN ZANDEN (Eds.), A history of market performance : from ancient Babylonia to the modern world (pp. 308-338). (Routledge explorations in economic history; No. 68). Oxon: Routledge.
LIU, Guanglin. / Market integration in China, AD 960-1644. A history of market performance : from ancient Babylonia to the modern world. editor / R. J. VAN DER SPEK ; Bas VAN LEEUWEN ; Jan Luiten VAN ZANDEN. Oxon : Routledge, 2014. pp. 308-338 (Routledge explorations in economic history; 68).
@inbook{c34923a0e69143ce9902a8ee1eb00421,
title = "Market integration in China, AD 960-1644",
abstract = "This chapter explores the market performance in pre-industrial China by comparing food prices and per capita money stocks in the Song (AD 960 1279) and Ming dynasties (AD 1368-1644). As recent economic research seems to show, macro-level stability based on increasing market performance is a necessary, although not sufficient, condition for pre-industrial growth. This increase in a pre-industrial economy would reduce the price volatility caused by harvest failures and promote specialization of production. All this advances agricultural productivity and improves the living standard of farmers and consumers alike. Other studies in this book have already identified a few contributing factors that help to explain market performance (i.e. lower conditional price volatility): trade, farming technology (increasing output), storage, consumption (if people started to diversify their consumption), institutions/government and monetary developments (which affect income and prices). However, in this chapter, because of the large monetary changes that occurred in China in the period under study, I focus my analysis on long-term changes in money stocks from the Song to the Ming dynasties to define and explain the performance of food markets in these nearly seven centuries.In the following, I first present a survey of long-term changes in grain prices in late imperial China. The survey clearly indicates the existence of two different price regimes, separated by the Mongol conquest of China in the late thirteenth century and the establishment of the Ming dynasty in 1368. The average level of food prices measured in silver remained much lower during the sixteenth century when the population grew and the market expanded. However, documenting rises and/or declines in prices docs not itself explain increasing or decreasing market integration. To explain the century-long deflation and its impact on trade, I further compare the money supply between the Song and Ming eras. This comparison points to a huge decline in money stocks between the eleventh and sixteenth centuries at both aggregate and per capita levels, and it was this decline that was chiefly responsible for the lower price level in the sixteenth century.The contraction or expansion of the market in the traditional Chinese economy essentially determines the monetary needs. I his chapter challenges the current wisdom about the transition towards a silver economy in the Ming era, which often assumes a deepening in the monetization of the economy and an enormous increase in the money supply during the transition, by providing a comprehensive measurement of the sharp decline in the money stock after the Ming dynasty was founded. The paucity of hard currencies was still felt even when China began to import silver from overseas trade. I argue that it was the anti-market policies implemented by the early Ming court (1368-1450) that substantially converted the whole economy into a barter economy and thus diminished the volume of hard currencies in circulation. The prevalence of payment-in-kind and counterfeit coins increased transaction costs and produced difficulties for long-distance trade. To test how currency affects market performance, I examine in detail the economic instability in the economy of the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries, an instability caused by the insufficient supply of hard currencies. Although this is the first time in the literature of Chinese economic history that an attempt has been made to explicitly relate long-term price movements to the quantity of money, the following analysis docs successfully demonstrate the important role that the money supply performed. In sum, the comparison reveals a regression in market integration from the collapse of the Song dynasty in AD 1279 through the Ming period.",
author = "Guanglin LIU",
year = "2014",
month = "8",
day = "21",
language = "English",
isbn = "9780415635448",
series = "Routledge explorations in economic history",
publisher = "Routledge",
number = "68",
pages = "308--338",
editor = "{VAN DER SPEK}, {R. J.} and {VAN LEEUWEN}, Bas and {VAN ZANDEN}, {Jan Luiten}",
booktitle = "A history of market performance : from ancient Babylonia to the modern world",
address = "United Kingdom",

}

LIU, G 2014, Market integration in China, AD 960-1644. in RJ VAN DER SPEK, B VAN LEEUWEN & JL VAN ZANDEN (eds), A history of market performance : from ancient Babylonia to the modern world. Routledge explorations in economic history, no. 68, Routledge, Oxon, pp. 308-338.

Market integration in China, AD 960-1644. / LIU, Guanglin.

A history of market performance : from ancient Babylonia to the modern world. ed. / R. J. VAN DER SPEK; Bas VAN LEEUWEN; Jan Luiten VAN ZANDEN. Oxon : Routledge, 2014. p. 308-338 (Routledge explorations in economic history; No. 68).

Research output: Book Chapters | Papers in Conference ProceedingsBook ChapterResearchpeer-review

TY - CHAP

T1 - Market integration in China, AD 960-1644

AU - LIU, Guanglin

PY - 2014/8/21

Y1 - 2014/8/21

N2 - This chapter explores the market performance in pre-industrial China by comparing food prices and per capita money stocks in the Song (AD 960 1279) and Ming dynasties (AD 1368-1644). As recent economic research seems to show, macro-level stability based on increasing market performance is a necessary, although not sufficient, condition for pre-industrial growth. This increase in a pre-industrial economy would reduce the price volatility caused by harvest failures and promote specialization of production. All this advances agricultural productivity and improves the living standard of farmers and consumers alike. Other studies in this book have already identified a few contributing factors that help to explain market performance (i.e. lower conditional price volatility): trade, farming technology (increasing output), storage, consumption (if people started to diversify their consumption), institutions/government and monetary developments (which affect income and prices). However, in this chapter, because of the large monetary changes that occurred in China in the period under study, I focus my analysis on long-term changes in money stocks from the Song to the Ming dynasties to define and explain the performance of food markets in these nearly seven centuries.In the following, I first present a survey of long-term changes in grain prices in late imperial China. The survey clearly indicates the existence of two different price regimes, separated by the Mongol conquest of China in the late thirteenth century and the establishment of the Ming dynasty in 1368. The average level of food prices measured in silver remained much lower during the sixteenth century when the population grew and the market expanded. However, documenting rises and/or declines in prices docs not itself explain increasing or decreasing market integration. To explain the century-long deflation and its impact on trade, I further compare the money supply between the Song and Ming eras. This comparison points to a huge decline in money stocks between the eleventh and sixteenth centuries at both aggregate and per capita levels, and it was this decline that was chiefly responsible for the lower price level in the sixteenth century.The contraction or expansion of the market in the traditional Chinese economy essentially determines the monetary needs. I his chapter challenges the current wisdom about the transition towards a silver economy in the Ming era, which often assumes a deepening in the monetization of the economy and an enormous increase in the money supply during the transition, by providing a comprehensive measurement of the sharp decline in the money stock after the Ming dynasty was founded. The paucity of hard currencies was still felt even when China began to import silver from overseas trade. I argue that it was the anti-market policies implemented by the early Ming court (1368-1450) that substantially converted the whole economy into a barter economy and thus diminished the volume of hard currencies in circulation. The prevalence of payment-in-kind and counterfeit coins increased transaction costs and produced difficulties for long-distance trade. To test how currency affects market performance, I examine in detail the economic instability in the economy of the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries, an instability caused by the insufficient supply of hard currencies. Although this is the first time in the literature of Chinese economic history that an attempt has been made to explicitly relate long-term price movements to the quantity of money, the following analysis docs successfully demonstrate the important role that the money supply performed. In sum, the comparison reveals a regression in market integration from the collapse of the Song dynasty in AD 1279 through the Ming period.

AB - This chapter explores the market performance in pre-industrial China by comparing food prices and per capita money stocks in the Song (AD 960 1279) and Ming dynasties (AD 1368-1644). As recent economic research seems to show, macro-level stability based on increasing market performance is a necessary, although not sufficient, condition for pre-industrial growth. This increase in a pre-industrial economy would reduce the price volatility caused by harvest failures and promote specialization of production. All this advances agricultural productivity and improves the living standard of farmers and consumers alike. Other studies in this book have already identified a few contributing factors that help to explain market performance (i.e. lower conditional price volatility): trade, farming technology (increasing output), storage, consumption (if people started to diversify their consumption), institutions/government and monetary developments (which affect income and prices). However, in this chapter, because of the large monetary changes that occurred in China in the period under study, I focus my analysis on long-term changes in money stocks from the Song to the Ming dynasties to define and explain the performance of food markets in these nearly seven centuries.In the following, I first present a survey of long-term changes in grain prices in late imperial China. The survey clearly indicates the existence of two different price regimes, separated by the Mongol conquest of China in the late thirteenth century and the establishment of the Ming dynasty in 1368. The average level of food prices measured in silver remained much lower during the sixteenth century when the population grew and the market expanded. However, documenting rises and/or declines in prices docs not itself explain increasing or decreasing market integration. To explain the century-long deflation and its impact on trade, I further compare the money supply between the Song and Ming eras. This comparison points to a huge decline in money stocks between the eleventh and sixteenth centuries at both aggregate and per capita levels, and it was this decline that was chiefly responsible for the lower price level in the sixteenth century.The contraction or expansion of the market in the traditional Chinese economy essentially determines the monetary needs. I his chapter challenges the current wisdom about the transition towards a silver economy in the Ming era, which often assumes a deepening in the monetization of the economy and an enormous increase in the money supply during the transition, by providing a comprehensive measurement of the sharp decline in the money stock after the Ming dynasty was founded. The paucity of hard currencies was still felt even when China began to import silver from overseas trade. I argue that it was the anti-market policies implemented by the early Ming court (1368-1450) that substantially converted the whole economy into a barter economy and thus diminished the volume of hard currencies in circulation. The prevalence of payment-in-kind and counterfeit coins increased transaction costs and produced difficulties for long-distance trade. To test how currency affects market performance, I examine in detail the economic instability in the economy of the fifteenth and sixteenth centuries, an instability caused by the insufficient supply of hard currencies. Although this is the first time in the literature of Chinese economic history that an attempt has been made to explicitly relate long-term price movements to the quantity of money, the following analysis docs successfully demonstrate the important role that the money supply performed. In sum, the comparison reveals a regression in market integration from the collapse of the Song dynasty in AD 1279 through the Ming period.

UR - http://commons.ln.edu.hk/sw_master/5163

M3 - Book Chapter

SN - 9780415635448

T3 - Routledge explorations in economic history

SP - 308

EP - 338

BT - A history of market performance : from ancient Babylonia to the modern world

A2 - VAN DER SPEK, R. J.

A2 - VAN LEEUWEN, Bas

A2 - VAN ZANDEN, Jan Luiten

PB - Routledge

CY - Oxon

ER -

LIU G. Market integration in China, AD 960-1644. In VAN DER SPEK RJ, VAN LEEUWEN B, VAN ZANDEN JL, editors, A history of market performance : from ancient Babylonia to the modern world. Oxon: Routledge. 2014. p. 308-338. (Routledge explorations in economic history; 68).