Recovery and Social Inequalities : The Use of Capabilities Approach and Intersectionality Analysis in Exploring the Social Conditions for Recovery

Research output: Other Conference ContributionsPresentationPresentation

Abstract

‘Recovery’ has become a dominant discursive feature in the UK mental health policies. Under the neo-liberal context, the mainstreamed recovery services tends to promote individualistic recovery strategies. Such policies and services fail to address the structural inequalities that give rise to distress and mental ill-health or place sufficient emphasis on the diversity of intersectional inequalities among service users that shape recovery journeys. This paper critically engages with the concepts of 'recovery', based on a case study of Chinese mental health service users in the UK which explores how structural factors, such as class, gender and ethnicity, contribute to their diverse recovery journeys.
To shed light on the complex interplay of structure and agency in shaping recovery journeys, a synthesis of the Capabilities Approach (Sen, 1999, Nussbaum, 2001 and Hopper, 2007) and Intersectionality Analysis (Walby, 2007 and Anthias, 2006) was developed as an alternative framework. Repeated in-depth life history interviews were carried out with twenty two Chinese people having received a psychiatric diagnosis, recruited from three cities in the England. Findings showed that participants strove, sometimes cautiously, to retain and exercise agency to move from patienthood to personhood. Their journeys were shaped by social inequalities demonstrating that targeting social inequalities is essential for facilitating and nurturing meaningful recovery.

Drawn on the findings in the case study, this paper will illustrate in what ways the medicalisation process enhances or hinders the (re)development of capabilities. It will also discuss about the use of the Capabilities Approach and Intersectionality Analysis in exploring the social conditions for meaningful recovery.
Original languageEnglish
Publication statusPublished - 19 Jul 2014
Externally publishedYes
EventXVIII ISA World Congress of Sociology : Facing an unequal world: Challenges for global sociology - Pacifico Yokohama, Yokohama, Japan
Duration: 13 Jul 201419 Jul 2014
https://www.isa-sociology.org/en/conferences/world-congress/yokohama-2014

Conference

ConferenceXVIII ISA World Congress of Sociology : Facing an unequal world: Challenges for global sociology
CountryJapan
CityYokohama
Period13/07/1419/07/14
Internet address

Fingerprint

intersectionality
social inequality
social factors
mental health
medicalization
redevelopment
health policy
health service
ethnicity
gender
interview
health

Cite this

TANG, L. (2014). Recovery and Social Inequalities : The Use of Capabilities Approach and Intersectionality Analysis in Exploring the Social Conditions for Recovery. XVIII ISA World Congress of Sociology : Facing an unequal world: Challenges for global sociology, Yokohama, Japan.
TANG, Lynn. / Recovery and Social Inequalities : The Use of Capabilities Approach and Intersectionality Analysis in Exploring the Social Conditions for Recovery. XVIII ISA World Congress of Sociology : Facing an unequal world: Challenges for global sociology, Yokohama, Japan.
@conference{4b2a9a38cfa147e89f28ee749c5a757a,
title = "Recovery and Social Inequalities : The Use of Capabilities Approach and Intersectionality Analysis in Exploring the Social Conditions for Recovery",
abstract = "‘Recovery’ has become a dominant discursive feature in the UK mental health policies. Under the neo-liberal context, the mainstreamed recovery services tends to promote individualistic recovery strategies. Such policies and services fail to address the structural inequalities that give rise to distress and mental ill-health or place sufficient emphasis on the diversity of intersectional inequalities among service users that shape recovery journeys. This paper critically engages with the concepts of 'recovery', based on a case study of Chinese mental health service users in the UK which explores how structural factors, such as class, gender and ethnicity, contribute to their diverse recovery journeys. To shed light on the complex interplay of structure and agency in shaping recovery journeys, a synthesis of the Capabilities Approach (Sen, 1999, Nussbaum, 2001 and Hopper, 2007) and Intersectionality Analysis (Walby, 2007 and Anthias, 2006) was developed as an alternative framework. Repeated in-depth life history interviews were carried out with twenty two Chinese people having received a psychiatric diagnosis, recruited from three cities in the England. Findings showed that participants strove, sometimes cautiously, to retain and exercise agency to move from patienthood to personhood. Their journeys were shaped by social inequalities demonstrating that targeting social inequalities is essential for facilitating and nurturing meaningful recovery. Drawn on the findings in the case study, this paper will illustrate in what ways the medicalisation process enhances or hinders the (re)development of capabilities. It will also discuss about the use of the Capabilities Approach and Intersectionality Analysis in exploring the social conditions for meaningful recovery.",
author = "Lynn TANG",
year = "2014",
month = "7",
day = "19",
language = "English",
note = "XVIII ISA World Congress of Sociology : Facing an unequal world: Challenges for global sociology ; Conference date: 13-07-2014 Through 19-07-2014",
url = "https://www.isa-sociology.org/en/conferences/world-congress/yokohama-2014",

}

TANG, L 2014, 'Recovery and Social Inequalities : The Use of Capabilities Approach and Intersectionality Analysis in Exploring the Social Conditions for Recovery' XVIII ISA World Congress of Sociology : Facing an unequal world: Challenges for global sociology, Yokohama, Japan, 13/07/14 - 19/07/14, .

Recovery and Social Inequalities : The Use of Capabilities Approach and Intersectionality Analysis in Exploring the Social Conditions for Recovery. / TANG, Lynn.

2014. XVIII ISA World Congress of Sociology : Facing an unequal world: Challenges for global sociology, Yokohama, Japan.

Research output: Other Conference ContributionsPresentationPresentation

TY - CONF

T1 - Recovery and Social Inequalities : The Use of Capabilities Approach and Intersectionality Analysis in Exploring the Social Conditions for Recovery

AU - TANG, Lynn

PY - 2014/7/19

Y1 - 2014/7/19

N2 - ‘Recovery’ has become a dominant discursive feature in the UK mental health policies. Under the neo-liberal context, the mainstreamed recovery services tends to promote individualistic recovery strategies. Such policies and services fail to address the structural inequalities that give rise to distress and mental ill-health or place sufficient emphasis on the diversity of intersectional inequalities among service users that shape recovery journeys. This paper critically engages with the concepts of 'recovery', based on a case study of Chinese mental health service users in the UK which explores how structural factors, such as class, gender and ethnicity, contribute to their diverse recovery journeys. To shed light on the complex interplay of structure and agency in shaping recovery journeys, a synthesis of the Capabilities Approach (Sen, 1999, Nussbaum, 2001 and Hopper, 2007) and Intersectionality Analysis (Walby, 2007 and Anthias, 2006) was developed as an alternative framework. Repeated in-depth life history interviews were carried out with twenty two Chinese people having received a psychiatric diagnosis, recruited from three cities in the England. Findings showed that participants strove, sometimes cautiously, to retain and exercise agency to move from patienthood to personhood. Their journeys were shaped by social inequalities demonstrating that targeting social inequalities is essential for facilitating and nurturing meaningful recovery. Drawn on the findings in the case study, this paper will illustrate in what ways the medicalisation process enhances or hinders the (re)development of capabilities. It will also discuss about the use of the Capabilities Approach and Intersectionality Analysis in exploring the social conditions for meaningful recovery.

AB - ‘Recovery’ has become a dominant discursive feature in the UK mental health policies. Under the neo-liberal context, the mainstreamed recovery services tends to promote individualistic recovery strategies. Such policies and services fail to address the structural inequalities that give rise to distress and mental ill-health or place sufficient emphasis on the diversity of intersectional inequalities among service users that shape recovery journeys. This paper critically engages with the concepts of 'recovery', based on a case study of Chinese mental health service users in the UK which explores how structural factors, such as class, gender and ethnicity, contribute to their diverse recovery journeys. To shed light on the complex interplay of structure and agency in shaping recovery journeys, a synthesis of the Capabilities Approach (Sen, 1999, Nussbaum, 2001 and Hopper, 2007) and Intersectionality Analysis (Walby, 2007 and Anthias, 2006) was developed as an alternative framework. Repeated in-depth life history interviews were carried out with twenty two Chinese people having received a psychiatric diagnosis, recruited from three cities in the England. Findings showed that participants strove, sometimes cautiously, to retain and exercise agency to move from patienthood to personhood. Their journeys were shaped by social inequalities demonstrating that targeting social inequalities is essential for facilitating and nurturing meaningful recovery. Drawn on the findings in the case study, this paper will illustrate in what ways the medicalisation process enhances or hinders the (re)development of capabilities. It will also discuss about the use of the Capabilities Approach and Intersectionality Analysis in exploring the social conditions for meaningful recovery.

UR - https://isaconf.confex.com/isaconf/wc2014/webprogram/Paper50365.html

UR - https://www.isa-sociology.org/uploads/files/isa-wcs2014-program-book.pdf

M3 - Presentation

ER -

TANG L. Recovery and Social Inequalities : The Use of Capabilities Approach and Intersectionality Analysis in Exploring the Social Conditions for Recovery. 2014. XVIII ISA World Congress of Sociology : Facing an unequal world: Challenges for global sociology, Yokohama, Japan.