「儒家文化圈」學習現象研究之反思

Translated title of the contribution: Reflections on research on the "Confucian heritage culture" learning phenomenon

黃毅英, 黃慧英

Research output: Journal PublicationsJournal Article (refereed)

Abstract

亞裔學生在國際比試中彪炳的成績引起近年「儒家文化圈」學習現象的許多研究。部份以實地取得之數據作為剖析,另一些卻嘗試歸結到儒家思想、甚至孔孟之片言隻字。本文欲從方法論上考慮,提出此類研究應慎防論證中「過度儒家化」之傾向。

The brilliant academic performance among Asian students in international comparisons has initiated an abundance of research on the "Confucian Heritage Culture" Learning Phenomenon. While some have relied on empirical data, others have tried to attribute the academic success to Confucianism in general and the words of Confucius and Mencius in particular. The aim of the present paper is to raise, from a methodological perspective, the need of safeguarding from "over-Confucianisation" in various arguments.
Original languageChinese (Traditional)
Pages (from-to)73-81
Number of pages8
Journal課程論壇
Volume9
Issue number2
Publication statusPublished - Jun 2000

Fingerprint

learning culture
Confucianism
international comparison
academic success
performance
student

Cite this

黃毅英 ; 黃慧英. / 「儒家文化圈」學習現象研究之反思. In: 課程論壇. 2000 ; Vol. 9, No. 2. pp. 73-81.
@article{fb364c156e28439492e1d94b66346bd0,
title = "「儒家文化圈」學習現象研究之反思",
abstract = "亞裔學生在國際比試中彪炳的成績引起近年「儒家文化圈」學習現象的許多研究。部份以實地取得之數據作為剖析,另一些卻嘗試歸結到儒家思想、甚至孔孟之片言隻字。本文欲從方法論上考慮,提出此類研究應慎防論證中「過度儒家化」之傾向。The brilliant academic performance among Asian students in international comparisons has initiated an abundance of research on the {"}Confucian Heritage Culture{"} Learning Phenomenon. While some have relied on empirical data, others have tried to attribute the academic success to Confucianism in general and the words of Confucius and Mencius in particular. The aim of the present paper is to raise, from a methodological perspective, the need of safeguarding from {"}over-Confucianisation{"} in various arguments.",
author = "黃毅英 and 黃慧英",
year = "2000",
month = "6",
language = "Chinese (Traditional)",
volume = "9",
pages = "73--81",
journal = "課程論壇",
issn = "1024-0276",
number = "2",

}

「儒家文化圈」學習現象研究之反思. / 黃毅英; 黃慧英.

In: 課程論壇, Vol. 9, No. 2, 06.2000, p. 73-81.

Research output: Journal PublicationsJournal Article (refereed)

TY - JOUR

T1 - 「儒家文化圈」學習現象研究之反思

AU - 黃毅英, null

AU - 黃慧英, null

PY - 2000/6

Y1 - 2000/6

N2 - 亞裔學生在國際比試中彪炳的成績引起近年「儒家文化圈」學習現象的許多研究。部份以實地取得之數據作為剖析,另一些卻嘗試歸結到儒家思想、甚至孔孟之片言隻字。本文欲從方法論上考慮,提出此類研究應慎防論證中「過度儒家化」之傾向。The brilliant academic performance among Asian students in international comparisons has initiated an abundance of research on the "Confucian Heritage Culture" Learning Phenomenon. While some have relied on empirical data, others have tried to attribute the academic success to Confucianism in general and the words of Confucius and Mencius in particular. The aim of the present paper is to raise, from a methodological perspective, the need of safeguarding from "over-Confucianisation" in various arguments.

AB - 亞裔學生在國際比試中彪炳的成績引起近年「儒家文化圈」學習現象的許多研究。部份以實地取得之數據作為剖析,另一些卻嘗試歸結到儒家思想、甚至孔孟之片言隻字。本文欲從方法論上考慮,提出此類研究應慎防論證中「過度儒家化」之傾向。The brilliant academic performance among Asian students in international comparisons has initiated an abundance of research on the "Confucian Heritage Culture" Learning Phenomenon. While some have relied on empirical data, others have tried to attribute the academic success to Confucianism in general and the words of Confucius and Mencius in particular. The aim of the present paper is to raise, from a methodological perspective, the need of safeguarding from "over-Confucianisation" in various arguments.

M3 - Journal Article (refereed)

VL - 9

SP - 73

EP - 81

JO - 課程論壇

JF - 課程論壇

SN - 1024-0276

IS - 2

ER -