Spearcons for patient monitoring : laboratory investigation comparing earcons and spearcons

Yau Wai, Simon LI, Tsz Lok TANG, Anna HICKLING, Szeyuen YAU, Birgit BRECKNELL, Penelope M. SANDERSON

Research output: Journal PublicationsJournal Article (refereed)Researchpeer-review

6 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Objective: We compared the effectiveness of single-tone earcons versus spearcons in conveying information about two commonly monitored vital signs: oxygen saturation and heart rate.

Background: The uninformative nature of many medical alarms - and clinicians' lack of response to alarms - is a widespread problem that can compromise patient safety. Auditory displays, such as earcons and spearcons (speech-based earcons), may help clinicians maintain awareness of patients' well-being and reduce their reliance on alarms. Earcons are short abstract sounds whose properties represent different types and levels of information, whereas spearcons are time-compressed spoken phrases that directly state their meaning. Listeners might identify patient vital signs more accurately with spearcons than with earcons.

Method: In Experiment 1 we compared how accurately 40 nonclinician participants using either (a) single-tone earcons differentiated by timbre and tremolo or (b) Cantonese spearcons recorded using a female Cantonese voice could identify both oxygen saturation and heart rate levels. In Experiment 2 we tested the identification performance of six further nonclinician participants with spearcons recorded using a male Cantonese voice.

Results: In Experiment 1, participants using spearcons identified both vital signs together more accurately than did participants using earcons. Participants using Cantonese spearcons also learned faster, completed trials faster, identified individual vital signs more accurately, and felt greater ease and more confident when identifying oxygen saturation levels. Experiment 2 verified the previous findings with male-voice Cantonese spearcons.

Conclusion: Participants identified vital signs more accurately using spearcons than with the single-tone earcons.

Application Spearcons may be useful for patient monitoring in situations in which intermittently presented information is desirable.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)765-781
Number of pages17
JournalHuman Factors
Volume59
Issue number5
Early online date1 Jun 2017
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Aug 2017

Fingerprint

Patient monitoring
Physiologic Monitoring
monitoring
Vital Signs
experiment
Oxygen
Heart Rate
level of information
Experiments
Patient Safety
listener
compromise
Conveying
well-being

Keywords

  • spearcons
  • earcons
  • patient monitoring
  • auditory displays
  • Cantonese
  • alarm fatigue

Cite this

LI, Yau Wai, Simon ; TANG, Tsz Lok ; HICKLING, Anna ; YAU, Szeyuen ; BRECKNELL, Birgit ; SANDERSON, Penelope M. / Spearcons for patient monitoring : laboratory investigation comparing earcons and spearcons. In: Human Factors. 2017 ; Vol. 59, No. 5. pp. 765-781.
@article{cdcf301f70ed4da5993f4254324fc8fc,
title = "Spearcons for patient monitoring : laboratory investigation comparing earcons and spearcons",
abstract = "Objective: We compared the effectiveness of single-tone earcons versus spearcons in conveying information about two commonly monitored vital signs: oxygen saturation and heart rate.Background: The uninformative nature of many medical alarms - and clinicians' lack of response to alarms - is a widespread problem that can compromise patient safety. Auditory displays, such as earcons and spearcons (speech-based earcons), may help clinicians maintain awareness of patients' well-being and reduce their reliance on alarms. Earcons are short abstract sounds whose properties represent different types and levels of information, whereas spearcons are time-compressed spoken phrases that directly state their meaning. Listeners might identify patient vital signs more accurately with spearcons than with earcons.Method: In Experiment 1 we compared how accurately 40 nonclinician participants using either (a) single-tone earcons differentiated by timbre and tremolo or (b) Cantonese spearcons recorded using a female Cantonese voice could identify both oxygen saturation and heart rate levels. In Experiment 2 we tested the identification performance of six further nonclinician participants with spearcons recorded using a male Cantonese voice.Results: In Experiment 1, participants using spearcons identified both vital signs together more accurately than did participants using earcons. Participants using Cantonese spearcons also learned faster, completed trials faster, identified individual vital signs more accurately, and felt greater ease and more confident when identifying oxygen saturation levels. Experiment 2 verified the previous findings with male-voice Cantonese spearcons.Conclusion: Participants identified vital signs more accurately using spearcons than with the single-tone earcons.Application Spearcons may be useful for patient monitoring in situations in which intermittently presented information is desirable.",
keywords = "spearcons, earcons, patient monitoring, auditory displays, Cantonese, alarm fatigue",
author = "LI, {Yau Wai, Simon} and TANG, {Tsz Lok} and Anna HICKLING and Szeyuen YAU and Birgit BRECKNELL and SANDERSON, {Penelope M.}",
year = "2017",
month = "8",
doi = "10.1177/0018720817697536",
language = "English",
volume = "59",
pages = "765--781",
journal = "Human Factors",
issn = "0018-7208",
publisher = "SAGE Publications Inc.",
number = "5",

}

LI, YWS, TANG, TL, HICKLING, A, YAU, S, BRECKNELL, B & SANDERSON, PM 2017, 'Spearcons for patient monitoring : laboratory investigation comparing earcons and spearcons', Human Factors, vol. 59, no. 5, pp. 765-781. https://doi.org/10.1177/0018720817697536

Spearcons for patient monitoring : laboratory investigation comparing earcons and spearcons. / LI, Yau Wai, Simon; TANG, Tsz Lok; HICKLING, Anna; YAU, Szeyuen; BRECKNELL, Birgit; SANDERSON, Penelope M.

In: Human Factors, Vol. 59, No. 5, 08.2017, p. 765-781.

Research output: Journal PublicationsJournal Article (refereed)Researchpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - Spearcons for patient monitoring : laboratory investigation comparing earcons and spearcons

AU - LI, Yau Wai, Simon

AU - TANG, Tsz Lok

AU - HICKLING, Anna

AU - YAU, Szeyuen

AU - BRECKNELL, Birgit

AU - SANDERSON, Penelope M.

PY - 2017/8

Y1 - 2017/8

N2 - Objective: We compared the effectiveness of single-tone earcons versus spearcons in conveying information about two commonly monitored vital signs: oxygen saturation and heart rate.Background: The uninformative nature of many medical alarms - and clinicians' lack of response to alarms - is a widespread problem that can compromise patient safety. Auditory displays, such as earcons and spearcons (speech-based earcons), may help clinicians maintain awareness of patients' well-being and reduce their reliance on alarms. Earcons are short abstract sounds whose properties represent different types and levels of information, whereas spearcons are time-compressed spoken phrases that directly state their meaning. Listeners might identify patient vital signs more accurately with spearcons than with earcons.Method: In Experiment 1 we compared how accurately 40 nonclinician participants using either (a) single-tone earcons differentiated by timbre and tremolo or (b) Cantonese spearcons recorded using a female Cantonese voice could identify both oxygen saturation and heart rate levels. In Experiment 2 we tested the identification performance of six further nonclinician participants with spearcons recorded using a male Cantonese voice.Results: In Experiment 1, participants using spearcons identified both vital signs together more accurately than did participants using earcons. Participants using Cantonese spearcons also learned faster, completed trials faster, identified individual vital signs more accurately, and felt greater ease and more confident when identifying oxygen saturation levels. Experiment 2 verified the previous findings with male-voice Cantonese spearcons.Conclusion: Participants identified vital signs more accurately using spearcons than with the single-tone earcons.Application Spearcons may be useful for patient monitoring in situations in which intermittently presented information is desirable.

AB - Objective: We compared the effectiveness of single-tone earcons versus spearcons in conveying information about two commonly monitored vital signs: oxygen saturation and heart rate.Background: The uninformative nature of many medical alarms - and clinicians' lack of response to alarms - is a widespread problem that can compromise patient safety. Auditory displays, such as earcons and spearcons (speech-based earcons), may help clinicians maintain awareness of patients' well-being and reduce their reliance on alarms. Earcons are short abstract sounds whose properties represent different types and levels of information, whereas spearcons are time-compressed spoken phrases that directly state their meaning. Listeners might identify patient vital signs more accurately with spearcons than with earcons.Method: In Experiment 1 we compared how accurately 40 nonclinician participants using either (a) single-tone earcons differentiated by timbre and tremolo or (b) Cantonese spearcons recorded using a female Cantonese voice could identify both oxygen saturation and heart rate levels. In Experiment 2 we tested the identification performance of six further nonclinician participants with spearcons recorded using a male Cantonese voice.Results: In Experiment 1, participants using spearcons identified both vital signs together more accurately than did participants using earcons. Participants using Cantonese spearcons also learned faster, completed trials faster, identified individual vital signs more accurately, and felt greater ease and more confident when identifying oxygen saturation levels. Experiment 2 verified the previous findings with male-voice Cantonese spearcons.Conclusion: Participants identified vital signs more accurately using spearcons than with the single-tone earcons.Application Spearcons may be useful for patient monitoring in situations in which intermittently presented information is desirable.

KW - spearcons

KW - earcons

KW - patient monitoring

KW - auditory displays

KW - Cantonese

KW - alarm fatigue

UR - http://commons.ln.edu.hk/sw_master/6704

UR - https://www.scopus.com/inward/record.uri?eid=2-s2.0-85024118838&doi=10.1177%2f0018720817697536&partnerID=40&md5=a7119d232e0d51e959e536bf4c996dc2

U2 - 10.1177/0018720817697536

DO - 10.1177/0018720817697536

M3 - Journal Article (refereed)

VL - 59

SP - 765

EP - 781

JO - Human Factors

JF - Human Factors

SN - 0018-7208

IS - 5

ER -