The apotheosis of montage : the videomosaic gaze of The man with the compound eyes as postmodern ecological sublime

Research output: Journal PublicationsJournal Article (refereed)Researchpeer-review

3 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

Taiwanese writer Wu Ming-Yi’s novel The Man With the Compound Eyes is partly about a natural environment inundated with the detritus of modern material civilization. But while he writes about environmental degradation, Wu does not necessarily accept the dogma of the Anthropocene, in that he describes wilderness scenes apparently beyond the reach of human development, especially in Taiwan’s central mountain range. In his depictions of nature, degraded or pristine, Wu tends toward a sublime aesthetic, the purpose of which is to convey a sense of ecological embeddedness: unlike a beautiful landscape, which can be appreciated from a safe distance, an ecological sublime draws one in, forcing one to experience oneself as part of an ecosystem. Like the recent documentary Beyond Beauty: Taiwan From Above (Kanjian Taiwan) (dir. Qi Bolin, 2013), Wu goes “beyond beauty,” with a view to reinscribing humankind in nature.

Sterk interprets Wu’s metaphor of a man with compound eyes in terms of the modern western sublime. The modern western sublime originally situated human subjectivity in relation to nature, but has been reinterpreted in terms of man’s technological supremacy over nature and in terms of postmodern media technologies that sometimes seem to ensconce us in radically artificial worlds. Most recently, the sublime has come full circle, except to nature conceived of as an ecological system. Yet, scholars who have discussed the ecosublime could do more to engage with theorists of the postmodern sublime like Fredric Jameson. In this essay, Sterk ecologizes Fredric Jameson’s postmodern sublime by reading Wu’s man with compound eyes as a symbol of the media technologies through which a sense of ecological sublimity (and a feel for nature’s subjectivity and agency) might be communicated to the smartphone generation.

The man is a metaphor for technological mediation because his “ommatidia” – the tiny eyes that compose his compound eyes – are not just vehicles for the gaze of nature but are also described as screens. In the tiny eye/screens play nature montages. Montage, in fact, suggests a model of intersubjectivity in which one can cut back and forth between different perspectives, both human and inhuman. Since the montages that play in the ommatidia integrate into a videomosaic, the man also shows the reader how to cut from an individual to a global perspective in which individual perspectives do not get pixilated. In this way, he suggests ‘hypersubjectivity,’ an alternative to Timothy Morton’s hyperobjectivity that has political potential, inspiring narratives of collective endeavor like The Man With the Compound Eyes.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)183-222
Number of pages40
JournalModern Chinese Literature and Culture
Volume28
Issue number2
Publication statusPublished - 2016
Externally publishedYes

Fingerprint

beauty
subjectivity
metaphor
Taiwan
dogma
intersubjectivity
ecological system
environmental damage
civilization
mediation
Nature
Apotheosis
Montage
symbol
aesthetics
writer
narrative
experience
Cut
Subjectivity

Keywords

  • Compound eyes
  • montage
  • nature
  • sublimity
  • subjectivity
  • novels
  • Chinese literature
  • memory
  • written narratives

Cite this

@article{81d086375f34414ba7e2650b0587364f,
title = "The apotheosis of montage : the videomosaic gaze of The man with the compound eyes as postmodern ecological sublime",
abstract = "Taiwanese writer Wu Ming-Yi’s novel The Man With the Compound Eyes is partly about a natural environment inundated with the detritus of modern material civilization. But while he writes about environmental degradation, Wu does not necessarily accept the dogma of the Anthropocene, in that he describes wilderness scenes apparently beyond the reach of human development, especially in Taiwan’s central mountain range. In his depictions of nature, degraded or pristine, Wu tends toward a sublime aesthetic, the purpose of which is to convey a sense of ecological embeddedness: unlike a beautiful landscape, which can be appreciated from a safe distance, an ecological sublime draws one in, forcing one to experience oneself as part of an ecosystem. Like the recent documentary Beyond Beauty: Taiwan From Above (Kanjian Taiwan) (dir. Qi Bolin, 2013), Wu goes “beyond beauty,” with a view to reinscribing humankind in nature.Sterk interprets Wu’s metaphor of a man with compound eyes in terms of the modern western sublime. The modern western sublime originally situated human subjectivity in relation to nature, but has been reinterpreted in terms of man’s technological supremacy over nature and in terms of postmodern media technologies that sometimes seem to ensconce us in radically artificial worlds. Most recently, the sublime has come full circle, except to nature conceived of as an ecological system. Yet, scholars who have discussed the ecosublime could do more to engage with theorists of the postmodern sublime like Fredric Jameson. In this essay, Sterk ecologizes Fredric Jameson’s postmodern sublime by reading Wu’s man with compound eyes as a symbol of the media technologies through which a sense of ecological sublimity (and a feel for nature’s subjectivity and agency) might be communicated to the smartphone generation.The man is a metaphor for technological mediation because his “ommatidia” – the tiny eyes that compose his compound eyes – are not just vehicles for the gaze of nature but are also described as screens. In the tiny eye/screens play nature montages. Montage, in fact, suggests a model of intersubjectivity in which one can cut back and forth between different perspectives, both human and inhuman. Since the montages that play in the ommatidia integrate into a videomosaic, the man also shows the reader how to cut from an individual to a global perspective in which individual perspectives do not get pixilated. In this way, he suggests ‘hypersubjectivity,’ an alternative to Timothy Morton’s hyperobjectivity that has political potential, inspiring narratives of collective endeavor like The Man With the Compound Eyes.",
keywords = "Compound eyes, montage, nature, sublimity, subjectivity, novels, Chinese literature, memory, written narratives",
author = "Darryl STERK",
year = "2016",
language = "English",
volume = "28",
pages = "183--222",
journal = "Modern Chinese Literature and Culture",
issn = "1520-9857",
publisher = "East Asian Studies Center, Ohio State University",
number = "2",

}

The apotheosis of montage : the videomosaic gaze of The man with the compound eyes as postmodern ecological sublime. / STERK, Darryl.

In: Modern Chinese Literature and Culture, Vol. 28, No. 2, 2016, p. 183-222.

Research output: Journal PublicationsJournal Article (refereed)Researchpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - The apotheosis of montage : the videomosaic gaze of The man with the compound eyes as postmodern ecological sublime

AU - STERK, Darryl

PY - 2016

Y1 - 2016

N2 - Taiwanese writer Wu Ming-Yi’s novel The Man With the Compound Eyes is partly about a natural environment inundated with the detritus of modern material civilization. But while he writes about environmental degradation, Wu does not necessarily accept the dogma of the Anthropocene, in that he describes wilderness scenes apparently beyond the reach of human development, especially in Taiwan’s central mountain range. In his depictions of nature, degraded or pristine, Wu tends toward a sublime aesthetic, the purpose of which is to convey a sense of ecological embeddedness: unlike a beautiful landscape, which can be appreciated from a safe distance, an ecological sublime draws one in, forcing one to experience oneself as part of an ecosystem. Like the recent documentary Beyond Beauty: Taiwan From Above (Kanjian Taiwan) (dir. Qi Bolin, 2013), Wu goes “beyond beauty,” with a view to reinscribing humankind in nature.Sterk interprets Wu’s metaphor of a man with compound eyes in terms of the modern western sublime. The modern western sublime originally situated human subjectivity in relation to nature, but has been reinterpreted in terms of man’s technological supremacy over nature and in terms of postmodern media technologies that sometimes seem to ensconce us in radically artificial worlds. Most recently, the sublime has come full circle, except to nature conceived of as an ecological system. Yet, scholars who have discussed the ecosublime could do more to engage with theorists of the postmodern sublime like Fredric Jameson. In this essay, Sterk ecologizes Fredric Jameson’s postmodern sublime by reading Wu’s man with compound eyes as a symbol of the media technologies through which a sense of ecological sublimity (and a feel for nature’s subjectivity and agency) might be communicated to the smartphone generation.The man is a metaphor for technological mediation because his “ommatidia” – the tiny eyes that compose his compound eyes – are not just vehicles for the gaze of nature but are also described as screens. In the tiny eye/screens play nature montages. Montage, in fact, suggests a model of intersubjectivity in which one can cut back and forth between different perspectives, both human and inhuman. Since the montages that play in the ommatidia integrate into a videomosaic, the man also shows the reader how to cut from an individual to a global perspective in which individual perspectives do not get pixilated. In this way, he suggests ‘hypersubjectivity,’ an alternative to Timothy Morton’s hyperobjectivity that has political potential, inspiring narratives of collective endeavor like The Man With the Compound Eyes.

AB - Taiwanese writer Wu Ming-Yi’s novel The Man With the Compound Eyes is partly about a natural environment inundated with the detritus of modern material civilization. But while he writes about environmental degradation, Wu does not necessarily accept the dogma of the Anthropocene, in that he describes wilderness scenes apparently beyond the reach of human development, especially in Taiwan’s central mountain range. In his depictions of nature, degraded or pristine, Wu tends toward a sublime aesthetic, the purpose of which is to convey a sense of ecological embeddedness: unlike a beautiful landscape, which can be appreciated from a safe distance, an ecological sublime draws one in, forcing one to experience oneself as part of an ecosystem. Like the recent documentary Beyond Beauty: Taiwan From Above (Kanjian Taiwan) (dir. Qi Bolin, 2013), Wu goes “beyond beauty,” with a view to reinscribing humankind in nature.Sterk interprets Wu’s metaphor of a man with compound eyes in terms of the modern western sublime. The modern western sublime originally situated human subjectivity in relation to nature, but has been reinterpreted in terms of man’s technological supremacy over nature and in terms of postmodern media technologies that sometimes seem to ensconce us in radically artificial worlds. Most recently, the sublime has come full circle, except to nature conceived of as an ecological system. Yet, scholars who have discussed the ecosublime could do more to engage with theorists of the postmodern sublime like Fredric Jameson. In this essay, Sterk ecologizes Fredric Jameson’s postmodern sublime by reading Wu’s man with compound eyes as a symbol of the media technologies through which a sense of ecological sublimity (and a feel for nature’s subjectivity and agency) might be communicated to the smartphone generation.The man is a metaphor for technological mediation because his “ommatidia” – the tiny eyes that compose his compound eyes – are not just vehicles for the gaze of nature but are also described as screens. In the tiny eye/screens play nature montages. Montage, in fact, suggests a model of intersubjectivity in which one can cut back and forth between different perspectives, both human and inhuman. Since the montages that play in the ommatidia integrate into a videomosaic, the man also shows the reader how to cut from an individual to a global perspective in which individual perspectives do not get pixilated. In this way, he suggests ‘hypersubjectivity,’ an alternative to Timothy Morton’s hyperobjectivity that has political potential, inspiring narratives of collective endeavor like The Man With the Compound Eyes.

KW - Compound eyes

KW - montage

KW - nature

KW - sublimity

KW - subjectivity

KW - novels

KW - Chinese literature

KW - memory

KW - written narratives

UR - http://www.academia.edu/33981474/The_Apotheosis_of_Montage_The_Videomosaic_Gaze_of_the_Man_With_the_Compound_Eyes_as_Postmodern_Ecological_Sublime

UR - http://commons.ln.edu.hk/sw_master/5834

UR - http://www.scopus.com/inward/record.url?scp=85007530354&partnerID=8YFLogxK

M3 - Journal Article (refereed)

VL - 28

SP - 183

EP - 222

JO - Modern Chinese Literature and Culture

JF - Modern Chinese Literature and Culture

SN - 1520-9857

IS - 2

ER -