The Mind as a Swiss Army Knife : Assessing Arguments in Favor of the Massive Modularity Hypothesis

Joseph David De Jesús VILLENA SALDAÑA

Research output: Other Conference ContributionsPosterResearchpeer-review

Abstract

Evolutionary psychologists have strong claims about the origin, architecture, and functioning of the mind. After getting rid of the Lockean metaphor of the mind as a tabula rasa or blank slate, they introduce a new one: the mind as a Swiss Army knife. They argue that human mind is “not a general-purpose computer but a collection of instincts adapted for solving evolutionarily significant problems - the mind as a Swiss Army knife” (Pinker, 1994, p. 420). This means that our behavior is produced by hundreds of innate domain-specific psychological mechanisms or “mental organs” (massive modularity hypothesis) that evolved during a period of time that is coextensive with the Pleistocene epoch. Furthermore, we are invited to think of the consequent mental architecture as the “universal human nature”. I would like to assess the main arguments advanced in favor of the Massive Modularity Hypothesis as well as the method (reverse engineering, functional analysis) used for identifying the hypothesized modules in the context of evolutionary psychology. This implies an evaluation of the feasibility of evolutionary psychology since the Massive Modularity Thesis is one of its mains theoretical tenets.
Original languageEnglish
Publication statusPublished - 27 Jun 2019
EventThe Science of Consciousness 2019 - Congress Center, Interlaken, Switzerland
Duration: 25 Jun 201828 Jun 2019
https://www.tsc2019-interlaken.ch/

Conference

ConferenceThe Science of Consciousness 2019
CountrySwitzerland
CityInterlaken
Period25/06/1828/06/19
Internet address

Fingerprint

Army
Knife
Modularity
Evolutionary Psychology
Psychological
Functional Analysis
Human Nature
Instinct
Evolutionary
Pleistocene
Evaluation
Tenets
Psychologists
Organs
John Locke
Module
Human Mind

Cite this

VILLENA SALDAÑA, J. D. D. J. (2019). The Mind as a Swiss Army Knife : Assessing Arguments in Favor of the Massive Modularity Hypothesis. Poster session presented at The Science of Consciousness 2019, Interlaken, Switzerland.
VILLENA SALDAÑA, Joseph David De Jesús . / The Mind as a Swiss Army Knife : Assessing Arguments in Favor of the Massive Modularity Hypothesis. Poster session presented at The Science of Consciousness 2019, Interlaken, Switzerland.
@conference{b536f0f459d74ad0bff47de26baa583a,
title = "The Mind as a Swiss Army Knife : Assessing Arguments in Favor of the Massive Modularity Hypothesis",
abstract = "Evolutionary psychologists have strong claims about the origin, architecture, and functioning of the mind. After getting rid of the Lockean metaphor of the mind as a tabula rasa or blank slate, they introduce a new one: the mind as a Swiss Army knife. They argue that human mind is “not a general-purpose computer but a collection of instincts adapted for solving evolutionarily significant problems - the mind as a Swiss Army knife” (Pinker, 1994, p. 420). This means that our behavior is produced by hundreds of innate domain-specific psychological mechanisms or “mental organs” (massive modularity hypothesis) that evolved during a period of time that is coextensive with the Pleistocene epoch. Furthermore, we are invited to think of the consequent mental architecture as the “universal human nature”. I would like to assess the main arguments advanced in favor of the Massive Modularity Hypothesis as well as the method (reverse engineering, functional analysis) used for identifying the hypothesized modules in the context of evolutionary psychology. This implies an evaluation of the feasibility of evolutionary psychology since the Massive Modularity Thesis is one of its mains theoretical tenets.",
author = "{VILLENA SALDA{\~N}A}, {Joseph David De Jes{\'u}s}",
year = "2019",
month = "6",
day = "27",
language = "English",
note = "The Science of Consciousness 2019 ; Conference date: 25-06-2018 Through 28-06-2019",
url = "https://www.tsc2019-interlaken.ch/",

}

VILLENA SALDAÑA, JDDJ 2019, 'The Mind as a Swiss Army Knife : Assessing Arguments in Favor of the Massive Modularity Hypothesis', The Science of Consciousness 2019, Interlaken, Switzerland, 25/06/18 - 28/06/19.

The Mind as a Swiss Army Knife : Assessing Arguments in Favor of the Massive Modularity Hypothesis. / VILLENA SALDAÑA, Joseph David De Jesús .

2019. Poster session presented at The Science of Consciousness 2019, Interlaken, Switzerland.

Research output: Other Conference ContributionsPosterResearchpeer-review

TY - CONF

T1 - The Mind as a Swiss Army Knife : Assessing Arguments in Favor of the Massive Modularity Hypothesis

AU - VILLENA SALDAÑA, Joseph David De Jesús

PY - 2019/6/27

Y1 - 2019/6/27

N2 - Evolutionary psychologists have strong claims about the origin, architecture, and functioning of the mind. After getting rid of the Lockean metaphor of the mind as a tabula rasa or blank slate, they introduce a new one: the mind as a Swiss Army knife. They argue that human mind is “not a general-purpose computer but a collection of instincts adapted for solving evolutionarily significant problems - the mind as a Swiss Army knife” (Pinker, 1994, p. 420). This means that our behavior is produced by hundreds of innate domain-specific psychological mechanisms or “mental organs” (massive modularity hypothesis) that evolved during a period of time that is coextensive with the Pleistocene epoch. Furthermore, we are invited to think of the consequent mental architecture as the “universal human nature”. I would like to assess the main arguments advanced in favor of the Massive Modularity Hypothesis as well as the method (reverse engineering, functional analysis) used for identifying the hypothesized modules in the context of evolutionary psychology. This implies an evaluation of the feasibility of evolutionary psychology since the Massive Modularity Thesis is one of its mains theoretical tenets.

AB - Evolutionary psychologists have strong claims about the origin, architecture, and functioning of the mind. After getting rid of the Lockean metaphor of the mind as a tabula rasa or blank slate, they introduce a new one: the mind as a Swiss Army knife. They argue that human mind is “not a general-purpose computer but a collection of instincts adapted for solving evolutionarily significant problems - the mind as a Swiss Army knife” (Pinker, 1994, p. 420). This means that our behavior is produced by hundreds of innate domain-specific psychological mechanisms or “mental organs” (massive modularity hypothesis) that evolved during a period of time that is coextensive with the Pleistocene epoch. Furthermore, we are invited to think of the consequent mental architecture as the “universal human nature”. I would like to assess the main arguments advanced in favor of the Massive Modularity Hypothesis as well as the method (reverse engineering, functional analysis) used for identifying the hypothesized modules in the context of evolutionary psychology. This implies an evaluation of the feasibility of evolutionary psychology since the Massive Modularity Thesis is one of its mains theoretical tenets.

UR - https://www.tsc2019-interlaken.ch/app/download/7820884154/program_details_online.pdf?t=1562607572

UR - https://www.tsc2019-interlaken.ch/app/download/7833890754/program_abstracts_online_corr4.pdf?t=1562607584

M3 - Poster

ER -

VILLENA SALDAÑA JDDJ. The Mind as a Swiss Army Knife : Assessing Arguments in Favor of the Massive Modularity Hypothesis. 2019. Poster session presented at The Science of Consciousness 2019, Interlaken, Switzerland.