The paradox of control in participative decision-making : facilitative discourse in banks

Lorrita YEUNG

Research output: Journal PublicationsJournal Article (refereed)

11 Citations (Scopus)

Abstract

This article examines the question of control in participative decision-making (PDM). Control poses a particular problem in organizations today, as organizational survival is arguably dependent on the contributions of subordinates, whose viewpoints may diverge from existing organizational premises. The question of what kind of management control, if any, is exercised in PDM, becomes relevant. Yet, despite the heavy emphasis on the importance of language and communication in facilitating PDM, there is a lack of empirical research on the discourse features of facilitative management. The present article attempts to fill this gap by analyzing the pragmalinguistic patterns of facilitation in PDM sessions in three banks in Hong Kong. The findings indicate that facilitation follows distinctive patterns, using discourse strategies quite different from those of gatekeeping control. Linguistic features such as modals, pronouns etc. correspondingly exhibit a different pattern of use. However, facilitative discourse also displays certain features commonly found in the discourse of authoritative control, such as the use of questions, rephrasing etc. Wliile control is evident in the guidance provided, the facilitative manager may come to a point where positional power has to submit to the unfolding PDM process. The patterns observed can be accounted for by the particular organizational and cultural contexts of the management discourse.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)113-146
Number of pages34
JournalText
Volume24
Issue number1
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - 1 Jan 2004

Fingerprint

bank
Decision making
decision making
discourse
management
Linguistics
decision-making process
Paradox
Discourse
Decision Making
empirical research
Hong Kong
Managers
manager
linguistics
communication
lack
Communication
language
Facilitation

Keywords

  • Control
  • Discourse analysis
  • Facilitation
  • Participative decision-making
  • Pragmalinguistic features.

Cite this

@article{3458a6ff83c14317b346c4b44a2b57cc,
title = "The paradox of control in participative decision-making : facilitative discourse in banks",
abstract = "This article examines the question of control in participative decision-making (PDM). Control poses a particular problem in organizations today, as organizational survival is arguably dependent on the contributions of subordinates, whose viewpoints may diverge from existing organizational premises. The question of what kind of management control, if any, is exercised in PDM, becomes relevant. Yet, despite the heavy emphasis on the importance of language and communication in facilitating PDM, there is a lack of empirical research on the discourse features of facilitative management. The present article attempts to fill this gap by analyzing the pragmalinguistic patterns of facilitation in PDM sessions in three banks in Hong Kong. The findings indicate that facilitation follows distinctive patterns, using discourse strategies quite different from those of gatekeeping control. Linguistic features such as modals, pronouns etc. correspondingly exhibit a different pattern of use. However, facilitative discourse also displays certain features commonly found in the discourse of authoritative control, such as the use of questions, rephrasing etc. Wliile control is evident in the guidance provided, the facilitative manager may come to a point where positional power has to submit to the unfolding PDM process. The patterns observed can be accounted for by the particular organizational and cultural contexts of the management discourse.",
keywords = "Control, Discourse analysis, Facilitation, Participative decision-making, Pragmalinguistic features.",
author = "Lorrita YEUNG",
year = "2004",
month = "1",
day = "1",
doi = "10.1515/text.2004.001",
language = "English",
volume = "24",
pages = "113--146",
journal = "Text and Talk",
issn = "1860-7330",
publisher = "De Gruyter Mouton",
number = "1",

}

The paradox of control in participative decision-making : facilitative discourse in banks. / YEUNG, Lorrita.

In: Text, Vol. 24, No. 1, 01.01.2004, p. 113-146.

Research output: Journal PublicationsJournal Article (refereed)

TY - JOUR

T1 - The paradox of control in participative decision-making : facilitative discourse in banks

AU - YEUNG, Lorrita

PY - 2004/1/1

Y1 - 2004/1/1

N2 - This article examines the question of control in participative decision-making (PDM). Control poses a particular problem in organizations today, as organizational survival is arguably dependent on the contributions of subordinates, whose viewpoints may diverge from existing organizational premises. The question of what kind of management control, if any, is exercised in PDM, becomes relevant. Yet, despite the heavy emphasis on the importance of language and communication in facilitating PDM, there is a lack of empirical research on the discourse features of facilitative management. The present article attempts to fill this gap by analyzing the pragmalinguistic patterns of facilitation in PDM sessions in three banks in Hong Kong. The findings indicate that facilitation follows distinctive patterns, using discourse strategies quite different from those of gatekeeping control. Linguistic features such as modals, pronouns etc. correspondingly exhibit a different pattern of use. However, facilitative discourse also displays certain features commonly found in the discourse of authoritative control, such as the use of questions, rephrasing etc. Wliile control is evident in the guidance provided, the facilitative manager may come to a point where positional power has to submit to the unfolding PDM process. The patterns observed can be accounted for by the particular organizational and cultural contexts of the management discourse.

AB - This article examines the question of control in participative decision-making (PDM). Control poses a particular problem in organizations today, as organizational survival is arguably dependent on the contributions of subordinates, whose viewpoints may diverge from existing organizational premises. The question of what kind of management control, if any, is exercised in PDM, becomes relevant. Yet, despite the heavy emphasis on the importance of language and communication in facilitating PDM, there is a lack of empirical research on the discourse features of facilitative management. The present article attempts to fill this gap by analyzing the pragmalinguistic patterns of facilitation in PDM sessions in three banks in Hong Kong. The findings indicate that facilitation follows distinctive patterns, using discourse strategies quite different from those of gatekeeping control. Linguistic features such as modals, pronouns etc. correspondingly exhibit a different pattern of use. However, facilitative discourse also displays certain features commonly found in the discourse of authoritative control, such as the use of questions, rephrasing etc. Wliile control is evident in the guidance provided, the facilitative manager may come to a point where positional power has to submit to the unfolding PDM process. The patterns observed can be accounted for by the particular organizational and cultural contexts of the management discourse.

KW - Control

KW - Discourse analysis

KW - Facilitation

KW - Participative decision-making

KW - Pragmalinguistic features.

UR - http://commons.ln.edu.hk/sw_master/7133

U2 - 10.1515/text.2004.001

DO - 10.1515/text.2004.001

M3 - Journal Article (refereed)

VL - 24

SP - 113

EP - 146

JO - Text and Talk

JF - Text and Talk

SN - 1860-7330

IS - 1

ER -